Topic: [Feedback wanted] I made a help page about Image Quality

So below are the solutions to different cases

Please tell me which parts are wrong or fine.

Below links' images are NSFW.

Same type, Same resolution, Different size

case 1
name resolution size
A.jpg 1000x1000 100KB
B.jpg 1000x1000 200KB

if the image has not been uploaded, choose the biggest size

else, check their differenced image,

> if you can see the slightly colored outlines in it, then you can reupload it.

> if you cannot see the slightly colored outlines, then don't reupload it.

Different type, Same resolution, Different size

case 2
name resolution size
A.jpg 1000x1000 100KB
B.png 1000x1000 200KB

(?)Same as above

Same type, Different resolution, Different size

case 3
name resolution size
A.jpg 1000x1000 100KB
B.jpg 1010x1010 105KB

(?)compare two images by eyes ( zoom in )

Different type, Different resolution, Different size

case 4
name resolution size
A.jpg 1000x1000 100KB
B.png 1050x1050 200KB

case 5
name resolution size
A.jpg 1000x1000 100KB
B.png 500x500 200KB

for case 4 and case 5, both of them need to compare two images by eyes ( zoom in )

but in case 4, I thought B mostly wins.

Edited:above images are all from artist's websites, and two images' SSIM > 0.9 but not equal to 1

Updated by anonymous