Volteer133 said:
infantilism I think is closer to a bdsm sort of kink like objectification or pet/pony play, and isn't implicated either way with diaper, which is a thing I want to avoid.

Yeah, I think diaper would be ok.

Volteer133 said:
nightmare_fuel is more of a comedic tag

I raise you this post:

nightmare_fuel does actually block out almost everything I don't want to see, and it was that post that made me add it to my blacklist. The other two posts I've seen could be added by blacklisting their ID.

Volteer133 said:
But definitely scat, urine, watersports, young, incest, rape/forced, BDSM, gore, death, My_little_pony, maybe pokémon though I've not heard of may people violently hateful of that as much as mlp, hyper, vore, inflation.
Some other potential ones that I can see people wanting to avoid might be anal, intersex, overweight, foot_fetish, blood, macro/micro

I'd agree with all those except my_little_pony and pokémon. I'm not sure how I feel about overweight, it's not really a fetish and a few characters are often portrayed as being larger, such as bowser, and it's more of a subjective tag.

I still think the quick list should only contain fetishes that people might want to avoid, rather than series/copyright.

Like I said before, it's easy to dislike the cartoon but like the porn/art, and given the option to blacklist it without seeing any, a lot of people would, me included. So I'd say to have specific fetishes on there, as generally if you don't like them you're never going to like images that feature them, whereas series/copyright can be a bit vaguer.

Kodanis said:
I think this is a good idea, but who would decide what should and shouldn't be on it?

I'd say that we would, the people who talk about it on the forum.

Obviously the admins can change it, but I imagine if people reach a consensus then they'll go with what list we end up with here.