Topic: BUR: alias 123_amputee -> amputee part1

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #3263 has been rejected.

remove implication single_amputee (113) -> amputee (6519)
remove implication double_amputee (241) -> amputee (6519)
remove implication triple_amputee (32) -> amputee (6519)

This is just half of the script since they need to unimply then alia.
For this BUR, the number of limbs being amputated doesn't matter, the difference only exist among intact, amputee and no limbs and the need for limbs for less than nothing. So, 123_amputee should be alias to amputee.

#optional Quad amputee is meaningless when having more limbs than 4 and another tag is needed for losing all limbs.
If it is needed to fix this small flaw, the existing related tags are fuck_nugget and love_pillow, but they all implies the scene to be used, and I prefer to use daruma, which is used on Pixiv, since it only refer to no limbs without implying something else.
For the later part, I'm considering doing as follows:
unimplicate fuck_nugget -> amputee
unimplicate quadruple_amputee -> amputee

update daruma -> daruma_doll
update quadruple_amputee -> daruma
implicate daruma -> amputee
alias quadruple_amputee -> amputee

EDIT: The bulk update request #3263 (forum #343880) has been rejected by @gattonero2001.

Updated by auto moderator

The implications need to be removed first separately, before a second BUR can create the aliases.

watsit said:
The implications need to be removed first separately, before a second BUR can create the aliases.

I see what u mean

eduimudzz said:
What do you mean?

This BUR can only remove the current implications, since the execution of a BUR happens in random order, effectively (and a tag can't both alias and implicate something, causing an error). So the first BUR can only remove the implications. A second BUR needs to be made that creates the aliases, which can be applied after the first BUR (tip: you can enter this topic ID 35212 in the BUR creation page to have that BUR appear in this thread).

eduimudzz said:
update daruma -> daruma_doll
update quadruple_amputee -> daruma
implicate daruma -> amputee
alias quadruple_amputee -> amputee

why even? we don't need more tags that would force users to look at a wiki to understand what a tag's for; tags should always be easy to understand just by reading the tag's name and hard to mistag without context, this tag fails both of these.

and I don't see much of a reason to alias away any these tags, they're kind of sparsely tagged but they can help immensely when a user's trying to find an image from memory.

darryus said:
why even? we don't need more tags that would force users to look at a wiki to understand what a tag's for; tags should always be easy to understand just by reading the tag's name and hard to mistag without context, this tag fails both of these.

and I don't see much of a reason to alias away any these tags, they're kind of sparsely tagged but they can help immensely when a user's trying to find an image from memory.

That’s not this BUR for, the part you quoted is just something related I'm thinking about but didn't put into the scripts. I make more readable and pls check it again.

Updated

  • 1