Topic: [REJECTED] Tag alias: does_this_look_like_the_face_of_mercy -> invalid_tag

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

errorist said:
Better question is, why are there no posts for it? Were they all purged?

EDIT: Ah, it appears that they weren't, but the tag itself was. Repeatedly.

A total of four different images. Only two of the images it was removed from had any relevance to the original face, one being the original comic page itself, and the other being a standalone image of the original comic's frame with meme-text on it. The other uses were just creepy faces.

Those two have clearly been the subject of an edit war, which we should probably figure out what to do about. And this seems like a good a place as any. Do we acknowledge this tag's validity by attaching it to the only two posts we know it applies to, or do we mark it as invalid even though we have plenty of other tags for memes, sometimes with only one post apiece? Doing neither seems like refusal to deal with the issue.

I don't know if this is really a useful tag in the current state. the only two posts which have ever had the tag applied in a valid sense were the source of the meme.

I bet there are other posts out there that reference the meme; they were just never spotted by someone who knew the tag existed. And even if they were curious and started typing it into the search bar, it wouldn't autocomplete because tags with no hits are treated like they don't exist (which is as it should be; the database is full of zero-hit tags that got put in and then removed for being typos or whatever).