@Genjar:

Genjar said:
If the userbase can't tag even one broad type of ferals consistently, do you really expect that splitting it into multiples would keep it in better order?

Not necessarily splitting it, but allowing further differentiation. Something like

• feral
• [tag for less realistic/toony ferals]
• realistic_feral_bodytype

-

The first one is a mistagged anthro , but I fail to see what's inconsistent about the other four.

See:

titanmelon said:
which is the point exactly;

Some people are going to consider it feral, some anthro, some in-between

the main point here, even if we ignore potential 'mistags', is the possibility of multiple feral body types existing

Based on a combination of factors such as art style, anatomy, poses, expressions etc

There's also an entire forum about this (not from me, for once) discussing why feral is a very broad tag

I'll add some relevant posts and counterpoints in here and to OP soon