I saw someone who was banned for creepy comments, but the sources it listed seemed pretty normal. Stuff like "I can go either way.", or talking about about how he'd like someone to smell like his rear for two months like the picture.
https://e621.net/user_feedbacks?search%5Buser_id%5D=828030

They're all expressions of desire that are inappropriate due to sexual or fetish content. Nobody wants to know that you'd be cool with being a small animal that gets its ass gaped. Nobody wants to know how much of a raging hard-on you'd have if you could make somebody smell like your anus for multiple months.

lafcadio said:
They're all expressions of desire that are inappropriate due to sexual or fetish content. Nobody wants to know that you'd be cool with being a small animal that gets its ass gaped. Nobody wants to know how much of a raging hard-on you'd have if you could make somebody smell like your anus for multiple months.

That sucks. But I can't argue with the rules. I'll abide by the rules and won't bring up a case like this again.

It's about the cold feeling you get when reading the comment.

dubsthefox said:
It's about the cold feeling you get when reading the comment.

I know the feeling you're talking about, but am unsure how to describe it. Like you're being forced into a fetish that you don't have? That's all I can think of, but it's probably not accurate...

acesteele said:
I saw someone who was banned for creepy comments, but the sources it listed seemed pretty normal. Stuff like "I can go either way.", or talking about about how he'd like someone to smell like his rear for two months like the picture.
https://e621.net/user_feedbacks?search%5Buser_id%5D=828030

It's easy: just don't make it about you.

I know, it's hard for many people on this site to conceive that they don't have to be the center of attention which is why they just get so befuddled when you tell them to stop making themselves the center of attention, but that's all it is.

Don't make the comment about you, and you'll never run afoul of the creepy comments rule.

lafcadio said:
Nobody wants to know that you'd be cool with being a small animal that gets its ass gaped. Nobody wants to know how much of a raging hard-on you'd have if you could make somebody smell like your anus for multiple months.

I wouldn't be so sure with saying "nobody". There are people who enjoy reading such statements.

acesteele said:
I saw someone who was banned for creepy comments, but the sources it listed seemed pretty normal. Stuff like "I can go either way."

acesteele said:
talking about about how he'd like someone to smell like his rear for two months like the picture.

Yeah, I wouldn't put those two comments in the same category. There's a big difference between essentially going "both are good" in regards to pokemon and saying you want someone to smell like your ass.

Anyways, yeah, I'd say it's already been mentioned. Don't make comments that shift the focus away from the picture. That includes:

-Comments about yourself personally (see: the 2nd quote in this post)
-Roleplaying (I certainly don't want to imagine some nasty ass guy pretending to be the character)
-Your OCs (if they aren't in the image)

I can't think of a single time in my life where I've read these type of comments and been happy about it. Not in all the years I've been looking at both porn and art. Neither drawn or real-life.

ebea57 said:
I wouldn't be so sure with saying "nobody". There are people who enjoy reading such statements.

You know exactly what I mean, don't be a pedant.
Even if you'd rather pretend you don't: creepy comments are still creepy even if people agree with you.

The line is pretty much wherever they feel like at the moment. There aren't any exact definitions in the rules.

lafcadio said:
You know exactly what I mean, don't be a pedant.
Even if you'd rather pretend you don't: creepy comments are still creepy even if people agree with you.

Some of those, I can see where the warnings are coming from. Others, I have no idea. Like

Mommy seems to be into it. Daddy, not so much.

That... just seems to be a matter-of-fact statement.

lendrimujina said:

Mommy seems to be into it. Daddy, not so much.

That... just seems to be a matter-of-fact statement.

"Mommy and Daddy" are self-referring terms. "The mom and the dad" make it third-person.

furrin_gok said:

That... just seems to be a matter-of-fact statement.

"Mommy and Daddy" are self-referring terms. "The mom and the dad" make it third-person.

That seems like a stretch, IMO. I've seen those terms used plenty of times when just talking casually about parent characters being cutesy.

That said, the picture that comment was attached to seems to have been deleted (or I have a tag on it blacklisted?), so I don't know the context...

I guess nothing overly sexual. You can make jokes, compliments, and observations, but no fantasizing it seems. Roleplaying has a lower bar for a comment being seen as creepy as well, so be careful with that.

lendrimujina said:
That said, the picture that comment was attached to seems to have been deleted (or I have a tag on it blacklisted?), so I don't know the context...

Just click the last source link to see it.

dogenzaka said:
That seems like a stretch, IMO. I've seen those terms used plenty of times when just talking casually about parent characters being cutesy.

I have to disappoint you. It was posts #1767347 if you click on the inkbunny link to the left of it, you can find it. Mommy is giving a handjob to daddy and daddy is cumming on his cub daughter, cutaway with a sweat drop from the daddies' direction.