Topic: Tag Alias: comparing_breasts -> breast_comparison

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

leomole said:
Aliasing comparing_breasts → breast_comparison
Link to alias

Reason:

Moving everything to one place

This is complicated. On the one hand, there's the comparing_breasts, which fits with the newly-established "[Verb]ing [Noun]" syntax. On the other hand, the breast_comparison might be a better choice so that it aligns with the other breast tags.

Ugh, dammit, why does the syntax have to fail me now? +1 to OP.

Updated by anonymous

leomole

Former Staff

I think you're right, comparing_breasts is a better fit, though it would be nice to have all the breast-related tags together.

Updated by anonymous

comparing and comparison also exist as two separate tags, not sure if that's intended. I think comparing is a better fit, since "comparison" usually indicates a visual comparison (such as a height chart) rather than the action of comparing (if that makes sense).

Updated by anonymous

Kida said:
comparing and comparison also exist as two separate tags, not sure if that's intended. I think comparing is a better fit, since "comparison" usually indicates a visual comparison (such as a height chart) rather than the action of comparing (if that makes sense).

Urrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh, more confusion. Para, please, provide input.

Updated by anonymous

Kida said:
comparing and comparison also exist as two separate tags, not sure if that's intended. I think comparing is a better fit, since "comparison" usually indicates a visual comparison (such as a height chart) rather than the action of comparing (if that makes sense).

It was suggested at one point to be merged but nothing ever came of it. If we are going to separate these two tags we'd probably be better off using a different name for one of them since the difference between "comparing_penis" and "penis_comparison" isn't very obvious.

  • comparing_* fits well with other tags that assume an action is taking place. This would be our "[two] characters actively comparing with each other".
  • "height chart" meaning has a few tags we could work from. I don't know that these really fit within comparing/comparison anyways.
  • Even though it shares a name, image_comparison (and maybe character_comparison) might work as a catch-all for side-by-side images. We could even imply image_comparison to multiple_images to reinforce that meaning.

Thoughts?

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:
It was suggested at one point to be merged but nothing ever came of it. If we are going to separate these two tags we'd probably be better off using a different name for one of them since the difference between "comparing_penis" and "penis_comparison" isn't very obvious.

  • comparing_* fits well with other tags that assume an action is taking place. This would be our "[two] characters actively comparing with each other".
  • "height chart" meaning has a few tags we could work from. I don't know that these really fit within comparing/comparison anyways.
  • Even though it shares a name, image_comparison (and maybe character_comparison) might work as a catch-all for side-by-side images. We could even imply image_comparison to multiple_images to reinforce that meaning.

Thoughts?

Ugh, my head hurts.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1