Topic: What is this i dont even... "Tag" Tag

Posted under Tag/Wiki Projects and Questions

I could see it being used for a "tag" object, like a toe tag, or price tag etc.
Or, for people playing a game of tag.

Updated by anonymous

Halite said:
I could see it being used for a "tag" object, like a toe tag, or price tag etc.
Or, for people playing a game of tag.

Tag needs a disambiguation, I'd say.

tag_(purchase), tag_(game), and tag_(id) are what I can think of.

Updated by anonymous

So far this is what I found in the tags for tag:

Tag
  • collar_tag - On a collar.
  • dog_tags - On a collar, or from a soldier.
  • ear_tag - That shape thing they put on cattle to track them.
  • name_tag - Name on a shirt, collar, bowl, etc.
  • price_tag - Something to mark price
  • spell_tag - I have no idea, but whatever it is Genjar tagged them and he'd probably know.

Other uses:

  • Tag - The game where people run around and try to touch each other for entertainment purposes.
  • Toe tag - To identify dead people.
  • Tag - As in putting graffiti on something. (only one under tag_(graffiti)
  • Tag(s) - A license plate in America.
  • Tag - Our tags, the best kind of tag. (there's a few meta-tag tags under tag now)
  • Tag - A small benign tumor ("skin tag")

My thoughts:

  • dog_tags -> dog_tag - Because I'm not sure why everything was aliased to the plural version in the first place. Nevermind
  • collar_tag, name_tag, tag - We should be able to combine most of these into something. The "name tag for a pet" is a common enough occurrence here that it could definitely be lumped into a single tag. I'd say use name_tag, but there isn't always a name (it can be just a symbol like with Housepets!) but collar_tag would probably work in most cases.
  • ear_tag, spell_tag - Leave as is.

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:

  • dog_tags -> dog_tag - Because I'm not sure why everything was aliased to the plural version in the first place.

Because dog tags are usually in pairs.

Updated by anonymous

Durandal said:
Because dog tags are usually in pairs.

Oh. I did not know that.

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:

  • collar_tag, name_tag, tag, dog_tags - We should be able to combine most of these into something. The "name tag for a pet" is a common enough occurrence here that it could definitely be lumped into a single tag. I'd say use name_tag, but there isn't always a name (it can be just a symbol like with Housepets!) but collar_tag would probably work in most cases.

Parasprite, we need to talk.

Dog tags are not what pets wear.

Unless you know any Catholic dogs.

Updated by anonymous

Due to the potential for confusion because there's so many different types of tags, I'd recommend aliasing tag to invalid_tag, thereby requiring the tag on the sidebar to be specific about what sort of tag is in the image.

Parasprite said:
  • ear_tag - That shape thing they put on cattle to track them.

Also on wildlife and other animals for the same reason. Basically, a tag-like object stuck to the ear without being an earring. Should also implicate ear_piercing.

  • spell_tag - I have no idea, but whatever it is Genjar tagged them and he'd probably know.

Basically, it's a slip of paper with writing on it that's supposed to cast or counter magic spells or repel the supernatural. It's common in Japanese anime and manga when dealing with supernatural and paranormal themes.

  • Tag - The game where people run around and try to touch each other for entertainment purposes.
  • Tag - As in putting graffiti on something. (only one under tag_(graffiti)
  • Tag(s) - A license plate in America.
  • Tag - A small benign tumor ("skin tag")

I think they should be retagged appropriately to reduce confusion, the first as tag_(game), the second as graffiti, the third as license_plate, and the fourth as skin_tag.

  • Tag - Our tags, the best kind of tag. (there's a few meta-tag tags under tag now)

The meta-tags by themselves are enough, I'd think.

Parasprite also mused:
  • collar_tag, name_tag, tag - We should be able to combine most of these into something. The "name tag for a pet" is a common enough occurrence here that it could definitely be lumped into a single tag. I'd say use name_tag, but there isn't always a name (it can be just a symbol like with Housepets!) but collar_tag would probably work in most cases.

An argument could be made that names needn't be written out as words, but could be represented by one or more pictures (hieroglyphics and cutie_marks, for example) or even a smell (as mentioned in the webcomic "Freefall"), although the latter is a bit hard to realize with current computing systems.

Identifier Tags:

  • name_tag – worn on a person or article of clothing other than a collar; can also be on other objects associated with a person
  • collar_tag – worn on a collar
  • dog_tags – specific style of identifier tags
  • ear_tag – worn clipped onto an ear, but isn't an earring; need not have anything written/drawn on it

Updated by anonymous

How about aliasing it to tag_(disambiguation) instead of invalidating it?
It has so many meanings and gets, um, tagged so often that it'd likely be the best way to keep those sorted.

As for spell_tag... Well, that's not really the proper name for it. But it's what Pokemon calls those and the other names are either too obscure or too generic (see http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PaperTalisman).

Updated by anonymous

  • 1