Should we keep the silly_face tag to when it's a character intentionally making a silly face, or include images where their face just naturally looks silly due to circumstances like being fucked_silly?

Intentional silly:
post #454500 post #254243

Silly induced:
post #237479 post #803526

Things that don't really fit either of those two:
post #665921 post #620879 post #167934 post #136484

Seems like the posts under that tag are a mix of posts that would be better off tagged as ahegao, smile, tongue_out or grin.

I'd say the best course of action would be to sort the posts into those categories and then invalidate it.

Edit: If a definition for the tag can be agreed on, sorting through the tag and removing posts that don't belong is another option, but personally I'd go for invalidating the tag.

FWIW...

• post #620879 has no business with that tag. The facial tag appropriate is annoyed.
• post #167934 is actually just naughty_face with tongue_out (or maybe licking_lip it's hard to tell).
• post #136484 looks like derp_face to me.
• post #665921 belongs in silly_face. He's clearly making a silly face at the viewer.

I'm wondering if a tag for people sticking their tongue out specifically to mock/make a face (as opposed to panting/ahegao/lips licking etc.) wouldn't be appropriate, but sticking_tongue_out has been aliased so I guess not.

Peekaboo said:
Seems like the posts under that tag are a mix of posts that would be better off tagged as ahegao, smile, tongue_out or grin.

I'd say the best course of action would be to sort the posts into those categories and then invalidate it.

Edit: If a definition for the tag can be agreed on, sorting through the tag and removing posts that don't belong is another option, but personally I'd go for invalidating the tag.

But what about the intentionally silly faces, where they stretch their face out or do some other related thing to give a purposefully silly expression? What else would we tag those as?

Furrin_Gok said:
But what about the intentionally silly faces, where they stretch their face out or do some other related thing to give a purposefully silly expression? What else would we tag those as?

If that's the definition that suits this tag the best, and people volunteer to maintain the tag, then I don't see any reason why we can't keep the tag.
That is, unless someone have a better alternative for tagging what you mentioned.