Implicating handjob → sex
Link to implication

Reason:

The wiki specifies that handjob is only meant for images where someone is stimulating someone else's penis.

It seems like this would qualify as sex, no?

Clawdragons said:
Implicating handjob → sex
Link to implication

Reason:

The wiki specifies that handjob is only meant for images where someone is stimulating someone else's penis.

It seems like this would qualify as sex, no?

Seems to fit the wiki's definition "Images or animations depicting any kind of sexual activity between two or more characters of any description." and so I'd agree handjob fits in there.

All the other tags in the "Sex Acts" section should then implicate to sex too. These ones don't currently:

ball_fondling
footjob
double_footjob
grinding
handjob
double_handjob
multi_handjob
reach_around
two-handed_handjob
hot_dogging
mutual_masturbation
oral

Well, double_footjob implies footjob, so if footjob implied sex it would be unnecessary for double_footjob to do so as well. Likewise for double_handjob, multi_handjob, and two-handed_handjob.

We should not imply oral to sex, because that tag is applicable for things like autocunnilingus and autofellatio, which are a type of masturbation, not sex.

Also fingering_partner should imply sex as well, and maybe be added to the wiki as one of the types of sex acts?

Clawdragons said:
Well, double_footjob implies footjob, so if footjob implied sex it would be unnecessary for double_footjob to do so as well. Likewise for double_handjob, multi_handjob, and two-handed_handjob.

We should not imply oral to sex, because that tag is applicable for things like autocunnilingus and autofellatio, which are a type of masturbation, not sex.

Good point thanks; wasn't thinking about the overlap. Edited accordingly

rezi said:
Good point thanks; wasn't thinking about the overlap. Edited accordingly

Actually I was wrong in part. The tag two-handed_handjob does not currently imply handjob. It should,, and would make this work, but doesn't, so let's add that to the list.

Clawdragons said:
Actually I was wrong in part. The tag two-handed_handjob does not currently imply handjob. It should,, and would make this work, but doesn't, so let's add that to the list.

Clawdragons said:
Also fingering_partner should imply sex as well, and maybe be added to the wiki as one of the types of sex acts?

Agreed x2

I noticed a few other things that may need cleaning up on the sex wiki page as well. ball_sucking is now aliased to ball_suck, so we should probably use the more current version, and the subcategory lists on the page don't reflect the subcategory pages themselves (ex. the "oral" section on sex does not contain oral_knotting, but the wiki for oral does)

rezi said:
(ex. the "oral" section on sex does not contain oral_knotting, but the wiki for oral does)

Funny that you brought up that specific tag 'cause a character can do that in a solo post with a knotted_dildo, hence very little sex ;)

Chessax said:
Funny that you brought up that specific tag 'cause a character can do that in a solo post with a knotted_dildo, hence very little sex ;)

Another good point! If this is the case, we'll have to unimplicate oral_knotting -> fellatio

Chessax said:
Funny that you brought up that specific tag 'cause a character can do that in a solo post with a knotted_dildo, hence very little sex ;)

There's also autoknotting, which is masturbation instead of sex.
Autofellatio tends to get tagged as sex because of overtagging, and the multi-tier implications make those hard to fix.

Clawdragons said:
Actually I was wrong in part. The tag two-handed_handjob does not currently imply handjob. It should,, and would make this work, but doesn't, so let's add that to the list.

Definitely.

Genjar said:
There's also autoknotting, which is masturbation instead of sex.
Autofellatio tends to get tagged as sex because of overtagging, and the multi-tier implications make those hard to fix.

True, but that doesn't feel quite right using that for tentacles or dildos, i.e. you could just as well knot yourself using someone else's penis just as well as using a dildo (not that you can tell from a picture anyway).

It's probably hard to keep those occasional solo + knotting posts away, so it's a payoff of letting very few posts get mistagged with fellatio/sex or let a large amount of posts get automatically properly tagged.

Speaking of knotting the same problem with knotted_dildos exists there as well. I'm not saying it's a very big problem, but it's still a problem, that, as you say, can cause grief.

I'd like to revive the suggestion that we implicate handjob to sex, as well as these:

rezi said:
All the other tags in the "Sex Acts" section should then implicate to sex too. These ones don't currently:

ball_fondling
footjob
grinding
handjob
hot_dogging
mutual_masturbation

Plus one to all except mutual_masturbation. Since that one still tends to get mistagged and probably needs to be renamed (...though that's been discussed a couple of times, and we couldn't agree on what the new name would be).

Genjar said:
Plus one to all except mutual_masturbation. Since that one still tends to get mistagged and probably needs to be renamed (...though that's been discussed a couple of times, and we couldn't agree on what the new name would be).

Mutual masturbation is not sex? Group masturbation sure, but mutual?