Topic: Using tags to convey story plot

Posted under Tag/Wiki Projects and Questions

The tumbler page where I got the Floatzel art of Barnabe include some hints to his story in the tags. I wondered of this is something e621 would refrain its users from doing.

Updated by Lance Armstrong

I'm confused about this post.

Tags on site should only match what's in the image, not "story" info outside what's currently seen.

There's no restriction on people's comments if that's what you mean though.

Updated by anonymous

We tag what we see, not what's been hinted to happen later. I can't think of any case where something you could see in an image would qualify as spoilers for later.

Updated by anonymous

OP is referring to a post's tags on Tumblr, not on e6. Those tags should not be used on this site, you should just tag what you see as per policy. You can put the artist's comments and/or Tumblr tags in the description.

Updated by anonymous

^ preferably in a somewhat sentencey way. (at least personally, just putting something like 'tumblr tags: foo bar baz' seems like it could invite unwanted "help" [transferring those tags to the post] from newbies)

Updated by anonymous

leomole said:
You can put the artist's comments and/or Tumblr tags in the description.

Yeah... I'd say that description field isn't meant for sharing another site's tags. It's more for official descriptions/stories. Sometimes other stuff, but can't think of a case where a list of tags makes sense.

Updated by anonymous

Wodahseht said:
I'd say that description field isn't meant for sharing another site's tags.

I mean Tumblr tags like what OP's asking about, stuff like #andthentheyalllivedhappilyeverafterexceptforthatthingwiththeasteroidsbutwedonttalkaboutthat.
Sometimes artists do that because they think it's cute. If you can translate that into something human-readable, it might be worth putting in the description.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1