Topic: unimplicate shere_khan -> talespin (and other related ideas)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Shere Khan belongs to two series:

Assuming the rights to The Jungle Book belong to Disney alone, we should instead implicate shere_khan -> disney.

Then we'll be able to tag the series on a case-by-case basis.

Other suggestions:

Also, apologies for not searching before posting. (forum #176025)

I thought this had only existed for so long because it had gone unnoticed.

Updated

The implication could technically work, but it is worth noting the Jungle Book is a novel in the public domain. However, for our purposes, we can do the implication because everyone will use the Disney designs.

Updated by anonymous

Isn't Talespin just a spinoff pun unintended of Disney's version of The Jungle Book?

Updated by anonymous

Character-wise, yes, otherwise, no. So an implication wouldn't stand because Rebecca was created just for that show. For the sake of argument, since the characters are significantly changed role-wise, I would argue for the unimplication.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

parasprite said:
Isn't Talespin just a spinoff pun unintended of Disney's version of The Jungle Book?

TaleSpin only had something like three characters from Jungle Book. Baloo, Louie, and Shere Khan (the latter only appeared in a few episodes).

The characters and setting were so different that I didn't actually notice the connection until years later.

BinaryHedgehog said:
However, for our purposes, we can do the implication because everyone will use the Disney designs.

Not strictly true. For instance, these are based on the Russian version of Jungle Book (The Adventures of Mowgli, and absolutely should not be tagged as Disney:
post #424768 post #424766 post #765359

post #437401 is one example of non-Disney Shere Khan. And I can see some posts under Jungle Book that are based on the original, instead of the Disney version.

So -1 for the Disney implications, and +1 for unimplicating TaleSpin. The current Jungle Book -> Disney is also problematic; almost half of bagheera_(jungle_book) are not by Disney.

I suggest a creation of a jungle_book_(disney) tag, which could be implicated to disney and jungle_book. Jungle_book could be tagged for all adaptations, while keeping non-Disney ones from getting implicated to Disney. Robin_hood and robin_hood_(disney) are already tagged the same way.

Updated by anonymous

BUMPITY BUMP FOR GREAT JUSTICE

+1 to unimplicate Shere Khan, as I ran into the issue again just tonight.

Updated by anonymous

o boy

seeing as it's been so long since this was suggested, it would be safe to check current tag usage before approving anything.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1