It seems silly to have milking to be aliased to breast_milking when there is an equal opportunity for it to be penis_milking as well. Both concepts are typically called "milking," so it doesn't make sense for only one of them to receive the "milking" tag. Since this will leave the milking tag without a home, I would suggest these two options:

1. Imply both penis_milking and breast_milking to milking.
2. Alias milking to milking_(disambiguation), informing the uploader/tag editor to change it accordingly.

I definitely suggest the second one, as breast milking and penis milking are incredibly different and it might have the adverse affect of some people tagging "milking" by itself without either of the two related tags, but I wanted to include it just in case. The second idea allows for more clean tag usage (such as how every type of "cuff" isn't implied to one "cuff" tag).

Penis milking is not actually milking. Neither is venom milking.

Milking is the act of extracting milk. You can't extract milk from a penis.

BlueDingo said:
Penis milking is not actually milking. Neither is venom milking.

Milking is the act of extracting milk. You can't extract milk from a penis.

yes, but even in your own text you specify that there's multiple kinds of milking. as long as people will accidentally tag "milking" when they meant something else, it seems like the more sensible thing would be to turn "milking" into a disambiguation page.

meowmcmeow said:
yes, but even in your own text you specify that there's multiple kinds of milking. as long as people will accidentally tag "milking" when they meant something else, it seems like the more sensible thing would be to turn "milking" into a disambiguation page.

It's not multiple kinds. Penis milking is a slang term for cum extraction. It doesn't count as milking just because the word "milking" is present, same as cum doesn't count as milk just because some people call it that.

BlueDingo said:
It's not multiple kinds. Penis milking is a slang term for cum extraction. It doesn't count as milking just because the word "milking" is present, same as cum doesn't count as milk just because some people call it that.

it's a slang term that's become popular enough to become an issue when tagging. i think it's fair to say that many users have mistagged or attempted to tag images with "milking" without realizing that the incredibly popular use of the word "milking" to mean "penis milking" in porn doesn't apply the way they thought it would and, in fact, completely flips the definition on the user when they had no intention of tagging sometimes as breast_milking. a seemingly major point of tag aliases and implications is to make adding multiple related tags easier to accomplish–i think having milking aliased to breast_milking obstructs this point.

yeah theres no need for a blanket tag for so vastly different things. just disambiguate milking