Topic: [Feature/Implemented] Remove the default rating on the upload page

Posted under Site Bug Reports & Feature Requests

This topic has been locked.

Requested feature overview description.

Main feature: Remove that rating:q is selected by default on the upload page, forcing the user to select one of the 3 ratings in order to upload.

Additional to help: At the same time make it so that the upload won't go through until a rating is selected, and give a descriptive error message / warning why the upload won't upload. Also add a small link to the rating page near the rating options to help users pick the correct one.

Why would it be useful?

Forces the uploader to select a rating instead of ignoring it.
It's a single click so it shouldn't be too hard, and with additional help (link to the rating page and telling people to look there) it should help preventing badly rated images on upload.

What part(s) of the site page(s) are affected?

Only https://e621.net/post/upload.

Updated by KiraNoot

I agree. One less reason to be lazy about uploading.

Updated by anonymous

-= -1

Tag history lists the rating changes so it would be possible for a tag researcher to analyze the impact of this change.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

Plus one.
Like I said before, I've never understood why it defaults to questionable even though that's the rarest rating on the site. Defaulting it to explicit would've resulted in less misrated posts, but forcing the uploaders to select the rating is likely better.

Updated by anonymous

That's right. I'd forgotten where it came from. Looking back it seems we discussed the very feature this thread is about! That's why it seemed familiar ...

Updated by anonymous

+1
When I'm concentrating on the tags I tend to forget about the rating.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1