Topic: Tag Implication: digiphilia -> interspecies

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

xenophilia → interspecies and xenophilia → alien
are probably not gonna work considering how the term xenophilia means kink for aliens, strange monsters, alien anatomy and unusual anatomy and not just porn of aliens with non aliens

Updated by anonymous

Commander_Eggplant said:
xenophilia → interspecies and xenophilia → alien
are probably not gonna work considering how the term xenophilia means kink for aliens, strange monsters, alien anatomy and unusual anatomy and not just porn of aliens with non aliens

Xenophilia in most circles traditionally refers to a fetish for aliens; teratophilia is for monsters.

Updated by anonymous

SnowWolf

Former Staff

Lord_Eggplant said:
xenophilia → interspecies and xenophilia → alien
are probably not gonna work considering how the term xenophilia means kink for aliens, strange monsters, alien anatomy and unusual anatomy and not just porn of aliens with non aliens

Well... we use bestiality which refers to ferals with things-that-are-not-ferals.
pokephilia is suposed to be pokemon-with-not-pokemon.
it's not unreasonable to use digiphilia and xenophilia in a similar way.

It/s... kinda like how a solo picture can't have a sexuality (ie, 'male/male solo' should have no results.)... it can't be xenophilia if there's not an alien boinking a non alien. If you're into aliens, then you should search for alien, yeah?

I think, anyway.

I mean, xenophilia seems horrifically under tagged, with 70 posts. ... considering there are 19877 alien posts, I kinda feel like there are not 19807 alien-pinups on e621 XD

and, infact alien sex interspecies has over 1500 posts

and alien sex -interspecies has plenty of alien-on-non-alien content

So... I don't think xenophilia is a bad tag, just undertagged.

Updated by anonymous

SnowWolf said:
I mean, xenophilia seems horrifically under tagged, with 70 posts. ... considering there are 19877 alien posts, I kinda feel like there are not 19807 alien-pinups on e621 XD

and, infact alien sex interspecies has over 1500 posts

and alien sex -interspecies has plenty of alien-on-non-alien content

So... I don't think xenophilia is a bad tag, just undertagged.

Couldn't have said it better! I'm terrible with wording things right.

But yeah... it is ABSOLUTELY undertagged, and could be useful if it were properly tagged.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

DiceLovesBeingBlown said:
Xenophilia in most circles traditionally refers to a fetish for aliens; teratophilia is for monsters.

Urban Dictionary disagrees.
Xenophilia is attraction to the unusual, including mutants, aliens, robots, and other sentient non-humans. As such, it's far too generic to be used as a tag.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar said:
Urban Dictionary disagrees.
Xenophilia is attraction to the unusual, including mutants, aliens, robots, and most other sentient non-humans. As such, it's far too generic to be used as a tag.

While this may be true for some uses of the term, the term actually has a pretty accepted definition that differs for FICTION; xenophilia has multiple definitions depending on context. Quoted from wikipedia:

"Xenophilia is a theme found in science fiction, primarily the space opera subgenre, in which one explores the consequences of love and sexual intercourse between humans and extraterrestrials, particularly humanoid ones."

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

DiceLovesBeingBlown said:
While this may be true for some uses of the term, the term actually has a pretty accepted definition that differs for FICTION; xenophilia has multiple definitions depending on context.

Yeah, in science fiction it's commonly aliens, which is hardly surprising: non-humans in scifi tend to be aliens. But this site isn't science fiction focused.

Sorry for being picky about it, but I've been on the xenophile mailing list since 90s, and get annoyed when people misuse the term. Most of the content on this site falls under xenophilia.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar said:
Yeah, in science fiction it's commonly aliens, which is hardly surprising: non-humans in scifi tend to be aliens. But this site isn't science fiction focused.

Sorry for being picky about it, but I've been on the xenophile mailing list since 90s, and get annoyed when people misuse the term. Most of the content on this site falls under xenophilia.

I can understand your frustration! But tbh considering what SnowWolf said: I do feel we could have a use for a tag of this nature, or at least in the "alien x non alien" nature, regardless of the name. Perhaps it could be named something else? I just used Xenophilia cause that's the most common known term for it in fiction, but maybe it's too broad.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

DiceLovesBeingBlown said:
I can understand your frustration! But tbh considering what SnowWolf said: I do feel we could have a use for a tag of this nature, or at least in the "alien x non alien" nature, regardless of the name.

Well, an another problem with that is that the alien tag has always been problematic. So far we haven't managed to form any consensus on how to even use it, and it tends to be tagged based on outside information instead of twys.

Consider these aliens, for instance:
post #1487578 post #1476608

First one looks like a generic furry, the second would be at home in most fantasy settings. Wiki even includes creatures such as cthulhu, which would visually be a better fit for monster than alien.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar said:
Well, an another problem with that is that the alien tag has always been problematic. So far we haven't managed to form any consensus on how to even use it, and it tends to be tagged based on outside information instead of twys.

Yeah, I don't disagree there. I feel alien is often just misused on a lot images, often tagged instead of just a general animal tag.

Updated by anonymous

SnowWolf

Former Staff

It really is an interesting question. what 'makes' an alien? what makes a monster a monster?

What is it that makes cthulu a monster while an alien from aliens is an alien? what makes a made up animal-liek species a fantasy race that is neither alien nor monster?

What intangibles make up these particular flavors of "otherness"? .... and why doesn't everyone agree? XD

Updated by anonymous

  • 1