Just to make it simpler and fold the terms into each other. I established a wiki with parameters for suckling to exclude its usage with genitalia (such as sucking balls, clit, or penis). instead folding that usage into oral_sex and/or ball_sucking.

hmm... I'm not sure if I'd want it to be breast_suck or suckling.

...Breast_suck is a lot more 'clear' about meaning... if one is looking at a picture of a blow job, 'suckling' might not be spotted as a strange tag, whereas breast_suck would be obviously out of place.

I think I"d prefer the alias to go the other way.

In other news, this might be a nice chance to deal with some of the other oral-boobie tags like:

• breast_lick
• breastfeeding
• breast_feeding (o.O;; well there's one alias already..)
• breast_bite
• breast_feed
• breastfeed (oh look, two more~)
• boob_lick
• boob_nom
• licking_breast

and any others I might be missing. Most of those are different enough things :) just need some unification and a lil retagging.

and aliasing.

(let's not talk about the mess that is hands-on-breasts...)

SnowWolf said:
hmm... I'm not sure if I'd want it to be breast_suck or suckling.

...Breast_suck is a lot more 'clear' about meaning... if one is looking at a picture of a blow job, 'suckling' might not be spotted as a strange tag, whereas breast_suck would be obviously out of place.

I think I"d prefer the alias to go the other way.

In other news, this might be a nice chance to deal with some of the other oral-boobie tags like:

• breast_lick
• breastfeeding
• breast_feeding (o.O;; well there's one alias already..)
• breast_bite
• breast_feed
• breastfeed (oh look, two more~)
• boob_lick
• boob_nom
• licking_breast

and any others I might be missing. Most of those are different enough things :) just need some unification and a lil retagging.

and aliasing.

(let's not talk about the mess that is hands-on-breasts...)

Working on this now. As for Breast Feeding, that is directly implying lactation. If there is no milk, its still suckling. So for breastfeeding you would want "suckling" as an alias. Suckling is directly a corallation to a mouth being placed on or over the nipple.

For lick its the tongue being exposed and running over the nipple/areola/breast and not being closed over it. I was going to work on those others once I had determined if this was a justifiable route to go.

The real issue is I see suckling being used in cases where the mouth is on the genitals when there are clearly better terms for these such as oral_sex and ball_sucking

Oh, I didn't mean to suggest that breast feeding and breastsucking were the same. I was more talking about the fact that we have breastfeeding breast_feeding breast_feed and Breastfeed all as tags, lol.

I do agree though and thank you for doing this :)

so, breastfeeding is if there is milk present (or presumably sufficient motivation to believe lactation is occuring, like a baby being attached to the nipple.

Vixxxine69 said:
Working on this now. As for Breast Feeding, that is directly implying lactation. If there is no milk, its still suckling. So for breastfeeding you would want "suckling" as an alias. Suckling is directly a corallation to a mouth being placed on or over the nipple.

I think you mean that for breastfeeding you would want suckling (or breast_suck/ing) as an implication? :)

For lick its the tongue being exposed and running over the nipple/areola/breast and not being closed over it. I was going to work on those others once I had determined if this was a justifiable route to go.

I think this is a fair statement and a good idea :D

The real issue is I see suckling being used in cases where the mouth is on the genitals when there are clearly better terms for these such as oral_sex and ball_sucking

Well, this is why I think suckling should NOT be a tag. I think suckling should be aliased to breast_Suck or breast_sucking... this way if someone puts 'suckling' as a tag on an imagewhere someone is ball_sucking or something, people will very quickly see that it doesn't belong :)

SnowWolf said:

Well, this is why I think suckling should NOT be a tag. I think suckling should be aliased to breast_Suck or breast_sucking... this way if someone puts 'suckling' as a tag on an imagewhere someone is ball_sucking or something, people will very quickly see that it doesn't belong :)

Not sure if you got what I meant.

I mean that people are placing a suckling tag on images where someone is sucking a characters balls. This is what I want to clear up. ball_sucking should be used in that case. Also images where a character is sucking on a penis is being tagged with suckling, while an accurate description it is far better to use oral_sex as it is a catch all.

I want breast_suck to be aliased to suckling, that is if someone types in breast_suck it changes to suckling.

In cases when breast_feeding is used, suckling should be implied and added.

Right now I am focusing primarily on establishing a relationship between breast_suck and suckling. If you prefer to use breast_suck to suckling that is fine with me. I was only using suckling because it is a single word and the first thing that comes to my mind when I see someone with their mouth on a nipple. I don't immediately think, "Oh he is breast sucking."