Aliasing holding_item → holding_object
Link to alias

Reason:

I had an issue with this the first time I tried to tag someone holding something. Item is a synonym to object.

EDIT: The tag alias holding_item -> holding_object (forum #246553) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.

I attempted and failed to make this same suggestion, so instead I'll +1 and bump this one instead.

The holding_item tag is a severely undertagged variant of holding_object with potential for future mistagging. Only 5 posts have the holding_item tag as of now, but I feel the tag should still be aliased due to it's potential to easily be confused with holding_object.

Bumping again and adding several other aliases/implications pertaining to holding_object.

Tag Alias:

• holding_item -> holding_object
• holding_items -> holding_object
• holding_objects -> holding_object
• holding_condoms -> holding_condom
• holding_drink -> holding_beverage
• holding_flowers -> holding_flower
• holding_mug -> holding_cup
• holding_coffee_cup -> holding_cup
• holding_photography -> holding_photo
• holding_weapons -> holding_weapon
• tissues -> tissue

Tag Implication:

D.D.M. said:

• holding_pistol -> holding_gun
• holding_pistol -> pistol

Might want to use the more generic handgun instead of pistol so that revolvers are included too.

Could also just add another tag in the implication chain, something like this:
holding_pistol -> holding_handgun -> holding_gun

JAKXXX3 said:
Might want to use the more generic handgun instead of pistol so that revolvers are included too.

Could also just add another tag in the implication chain, something like this:
holding_pistol -> holding_handgun -> holding_gun

• That sounds preferential. I had thought of adding holding_handgun to the list originally, but decided against it since it hadn't been used on any posts yet. It may be good to add holding_revolver into that implication chain as well.

• I'm wondering if the various clothing subsections should be made into similar implication chains as proposed for holding_footwear and holding_underwear? Basically, create the tags for the various clothing subsections (holding_armwear, holding_bottomwear, holding_topwear, holding_headwear, holding_legwear, and holding_swimwear) and have the specific clothing-item implicate their respective subsection tag (holding_shirt -> holding_topwear -> holding_clothing and holding_hat -> holding_headwear -> holding_clothing for example).
• Should there be a holding_headgear tag for holding_helmet to imply?

• I noticed that for some reason holding_dildo is simultaneously aliased/implicated to holding_sex_toy. I think having holding_dildo as a tag can be useful, but the alias/implication problem with this tag would need to be fixed before it can be utilized.

• Last but not least, I saw cutlery was a tag and wonder if a holding_cutlery (and maybe holding_cookware for cookware later on?) tag should be added as part of the holding_utensil implication chain.
• Another implication chain problem plagues holding_knife since it could either apply to holding_weapon or holding_utensil, except there doesn't seem to be a clear solution to this problem. In the end, posts may have to be tagged on a case-by-case basis.

+1 to all. Also suggesting aliasing item_in_mouth to object_in_mouth.

The tag alias holding_item -> holding_object (forum #246553) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.