I'm trying to clean up the autofellatio solo fellatio sex tag search and any image where a character is knotting their own mouth is automatically implicated to both sex and fellatio if oral_knotting is tagged.

post #1599832 post #1469913 post #1300611

I think it'd be a good idea to replace oral_knotting's implication of fellatio with oral_penetration instead.

______________________________________________________________________

This also affects images where someone is using a knotted dildo to masturbate with.

post #1359045 post #1397205 post #1339002

So I think it would also be a good idea to change knotting's implication from sex to penetration.

As a side note: I found a similar thread from 2015, and they suggest replacing any "knot" related tags with just autoknotting.

What does everyone think? I'd love to get some feedback on this.
(Edited to clarify my suggestions.)

So, just to be clear, the issue you're highlighting is that oral_knotting implies sex(2+ chars) and fellatio(exclusive from autofellatio), right?

I agree that a solution would be to implement self_knotting - defined as a character knotting themselves, either via autofellatio or via a knotted dildo. I say self_knotting bc I think autoknotting/auto_knotting would be too easily confused with autofellatio/autotitjob.

zavros-periculum said:
So, just to be clear, the issue you're highlighting is that oral_knotting implies sex(2+ chars) and fellatio(exclusive from autofellatio), right?

I agree that a solution would be to implement self_knotting - defined as a character knotting themselves, either via autofellatio or via a knotted dildo. I say self_knotting bc I think autoknotting/auto_knotting would be too easily confused with autofellatio/autotitjob.

I think autoknotting would be a good choice. Self knotting kinda sounds more like you're knotting yourself anally instead of orally. Autoknotting also fits in the the tags you mentioned, so it fits into an established way of tagging selfsex.

zavros-periculum said:
So, just to be clear, the issue you're highlighting is that oral_knotting implies sex(2+ chars) and fellatio(exclusive from autofellatio), right?

I agree that a solution would be to implement self_knotting - defined as a character knotting themselves, either via autofellatio or via a knotted dildo. I say self_knotting bc I think autoknotting/auto_knotting would be too easily confused with autofellatio/autotitjob.

Oh wait, what about Autoralknotting?

ThePyromancer said:
I think autoknotting would be a good choice. Self knotting kinda sounds more like you're knotting yourself anally instead of orally. Autoknotting also fits in the the tags you mentioned, so it fits into an established way of tagging selfsex.

wait, how does it sound like you're just knotting yourself anally?

zavros-periculum said:
So, just to be clear, the issue you're highlighting is that oral_knotting implies sex(2+ chars) and fellatio(exclusive from autofellatio), right?

Correct. Oral_knotting implies fellatio which automatically implies sex. So if a character is knotting themself during autofellatio, you basically have 2 mistags to go along with it.

Knotting oneself with a knotted dildo in whichever orifice would also have sex implied.

zavros-periculum said:
I agree that a solution would be to implement self_knotting - defined as a character knotting themselves, either via autofellatio or via a knotted dildo. I say self_knotting bc I think autoknotting/auto_knotting would be too easily confused with autofellatio/autotitjob.

Autoknotting is actually already a tag in use.

I just think it would be helpful for posts where this happens to be tagged with anal_knotting, vaginal_knotting, or oral_knotting as well, since they're more descriptive. Autoknotting sounds more like what you would tag with those tags, not instead of them.

ThePyromancer said:
Oh wait, what about Autoralknotting?

I guess if the implications are too important to remove, then autovaginal_knotting, autoanal_knotting, and autooral_knotting could be created. They seem a bit cumbersome though.

____________________________________________________

Just a note: I personally think knotting should imply penetration instead of sex and oral_knotting should imply oral_penetration instead of fellatio. Much less potential for mistags that way. (Updated the OP)