Topic: [APPROVED] Tag alias: grecko -> grecko_(disambiguation)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The tag alias #47149 grecko -> grecko_(disambiguation) has been rejected.

Reason: "grecko" is ambiguous and does not seem to refer to any single character, so send to disambiguation.

EDIT: The tag alias grecko -> grecko_(disambiguation) (forum #296126) has been approved by @furrypickle.

EDIT: The tag alias grecko -> grecko_(disambiguation) (forum #296126) has been rejected by @furrypickle.

EDIT: The tag alias grecko -> grecko_(disambiguation) (forum #296126) has been rejected by @furrypickle.

Updated by auto moderator

Are you sure you haven't etis'd this up again?

For starters, there is only one other tag containing the substring "grecko", and its one post has never been tagged grecko. Not really disambiguation material thus far.

Okay, let's look at the usage history of the tag. It has been added to 12 posts, and removed from only one, a year ago. The removal reason was that it was a typo for gecko. We've invalidated typos that could mean multiple things before, but we do generally require a sample size of more than one before doing so, especially when that one typo lasted for five minutes and was fixed by the same user who introduced it.

Of the 11 remaining posts, 7 remain undeleted. Let's check each one in turn.

post #1563750 A commission of a leopard gecko character sourced to its owner, FA user "grecko".

post #1560702 A commission of a leopard gecko character which the artist's source says was bought by FA user "grecko".

post #1254657 A commission of a leopard gecko character which the artist's source says was bought by FA user "grecko", this time specifically mentioning that the non-gecko character is owned by the artist.

post #951870 A commission of a garter snake character which the artist's source says was bought by FA user "grecko".

post #763856 A commission of a leopard gecko character which the artist's source says was bought by FA user "grecko".

post #694969 A female frilled lizard character. Found an alternative source which specifies that this was a commission bought by FA user "grecko".

post #100962 A leopard gecko character with no direct source. But I found one anyway on the "grecko" account.

While I'm at it, here's a reference sheet which confirms that the name of the blue leopard gecko is indeed "Grecko".

What about the four deleted posts? post #694540 is just an inferior version, but the other two were taken down.

post #571976: Source still up, leopard gecko on the right.

post #542777 and post #520054: Sources for both of these are on the "grecko" FA, and star a certain blue leopard gecko.

It has to be said that Grecko does not only commission his primary fursona (scalesona?). At the time of writing, the most recent post on his FA is of "Kik my velvet gecko kobold assassin". His own upload of the garter snake post makes it clear that this is not a named character ("Inspire by garter snake mating behavior that occurs after their communal hibernation", apparently).

So at worst you could say that two of the ten distinct posts were using the tag to refer to the commissioner, rather than the character. In other words, either the tag is valid or it should be removed entirely; there is no disambiguation to be made here.

Yep, it looks like this one may have been unnecessary. It looked like a mixture, but I wasn't expecting a few mistags of the commissioner being bundled into the character tag... to be the cause of that mixture. So I'll reverse it. Thank you for digging into it and figuring it out.

  • 1