Topic: Sketch_page in CHARS(-solo -duo -group -zero_pictured)

Posted under Tag/Wiki Projects and Questions

Ah, I meant to say that the wiki description should be edited. Because I don't know if it's okay to put multiple people counting tags.

leomole said:
Yes, it is okay to put multiple character count tags on posts that are sketch pages or comics or otherwise contain multiple images.

I'm not so sure about comics, I don't think you should put multiple character count tags unless there's a distinct scene change, the same way you wouldn't tag an animated post solo just because there's a few frames where only one character is visible.

I still say the character count tags should include unique characters in the post as a whole, and not try to delineate between panels or "scene changes" or whatever. Meaning there should only ever be one character count tag per post.

post #3162054
No one would benefit from this being tagged duo+solo and not group (I've looked over it multiple times and can't find a single panel that has more than 2 characters, and two panels seem to have 1 character). Yet there is no cohesive "scene", it's just multiple images of each gym leader with one of their pokemon.

post #208926 post #3225513
Who would honestly consider these solo, and use "solo" in a search for them?

And you get silly situations like
post #3259208
where the final panel is a scene transition, so should get the tag zero_pictured?

Not to mention various instances where there's no clear separation between "images"
post #2713947
so you can't tell who should be grouped together for a count or not.

  • 1