Topic: Tag Implication: piranha_plant -> flora_fauna

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

We have several piranha_plant pictures that are more cosplay than the actual species: post #564261 post #549669 post #511925 post #483442 post #483434 post #553969 and some flash animations.

EDIT: But, yes, it should be a species.
Implicating a fictional video game species to a broad category of species gets complicated because all members of the species tend to look exactly identical, which makes them similar to character tags. koopa -> scalie is accepted and probably many others, so the implication does make sense. Technically it would add 11 arguably incorrect tags (due to cosplay), but it would also add 65 correct ones.

Updated by anonymous

Deh-tiger said:

We have several piranha_plant pictures that are more cosplay than the actual species: post #564261 post #549669 post #511925 post #483442 post #483434 post #553969 and some flash animations.

While I agree with you that there is cosplay and it does confuses the tagging system, remember that we still have lots of wolf, pikachu, etc. cosplay, but it doesn't prevent us from using them a species. There isn't just 1 piranha plant that we can name (such as a boss like Bowser).

Anyways, unless we are going to implement a species_cosplay tag system, it's probably better just to use the species name + cosplay/costume in most cases.

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:
While I agree with you that there is cosplay and it does confuses the tagging system, remember that we still have lots of wolf, pikachu, etc. cosplay, but it doesn't prevent us from using them a species. There isn't just 1 piranha plant that we can name (such as a boss like Bowser).

Anyways, unless we are going to implement a species_cosplay tag system, it's probably better just to use the species name + cosplay/costume in most cases.

Yeah, +1.

Updated by anonymous

Tokaido said:
Flora_fauna, now that's a tag I didnt know we had.

There was a point where I was like that. Then I found the tag and was all, "Holy shit. I can look up those plant people without finding images that include the standard form of the plant."

Updated by anonymous

Approved.

I <3 the flora_fauna tag actually. The day I stumbled across it I felt like it was a tag I had never known that I needed in my life. =)

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:
There isn't just 1 piranha plant that we can name (such as a boss like Bowser).

I just noticed this line... There actually is one: petey_piranha

furrypickle said:
I <3 the flora_fauna tag actually. The day I stumbled across it I felt like it was a tag I had never known that I needed in my life. =)

Agreed.

Updated by anonymous

Furrin_Gok said:
I just noticed this line... There actually is one: petey_piranha

Neat, I didn't know about that one.

I'm way out of the loop these days.

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:
Neat, I didn't know about that one.

I'm way out of the loop these days.

There's also megasmilax, mom_piranha, and peewee_piranha, though they aren't on this site.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1