Topic: [REJECTED] Puss in Boots BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #3900 has been rejected.

create implication puss_in_boots_(2011_film) (0) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication puss_in_boots_the_last_wish (1) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication the_adventures_of_puss_in_boots (0) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication puss_in_boots_(series) (1) -> dreamworks (28456)
change category puss_in_boots_(series) (1) -> copyright
create alias puss_in_boots_(film) (0) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create alias puss_in_boots_2 (0) -> puss_in_boots_the_last_wish (1)
create alias adventures_of_puss_in_boots (0) -> the_adventures_of_puss_in_boots (0)
remove implication puss_in_boots_(dreamworks) (2422) -> dreamworks (28456)
create implication puss_in_boots_(dreamworks) (2422) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication kitty_softpaws (524) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication death_(puss_in_boots) (5222) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication sheila_(puss_in_boots) (12) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication dulcinea_(puss_in_boots) (80) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication pajuna_(puss_in_boots) (5) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication sphinx_(puss_in_boots) (8) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)
create implication perrito_(puss_in_boots) (234) -> puss_in_boots_(series) (1)

Reason: There are currently several copyright tags for "Puss in Boots" productions by dreamworks:

With this BUR I am proposing to

  • create a new supertag puss_in_boots_(series) for all of the above
  • create some useful aliases and implications, extending character -> copyright for all characters (that I could find)
  • rename puss_in_boots_(film) to puss_in_boots_(2011_film) to avoid confusion
    • There are currently ~50 correctly and ~100 incorrectly tagged posts that would need manual fixup.

Alternatively, we could also "squash" all the puss in boots tags into a single one if this is creating too much copyright tag spam.

EDIT: The bulk update request #3900 (forum #354556) has been rejected by @slyroon.

Updated by auto moderator

I support disambiguating puss_in_boots_(film) for the reason you mentioned.
I oppose imply puss_in_boots_(dreamworks) -> puss_in_boots_(series). It would be helpful, but puss_in_boots_(dreamworks) is from the shrek_(series) movies.
I would prefer to squash all the puss_in_boots copyright tags because I'm feeling lazy.

There's also Puss in Boots: The Three Diablos with the characters gonzalo_(the_three_diablos), perla, and sir_timotao_montenegro_iii under the tag the_three_diablos. I advise leaving them for a separate BUR, to make this one a little easier to review.

A few issues I have with this:

create implication puss_in_boots_(series) -> dreamworks

It would be nice to make it clear somehow that puss_in_boots_(series) refers specifically to the Dreamworks series rather than e.g. The Wonderful World of Puss 'n Boots by Toei.

change category puss_in_boots_(film) -> invalid

Why not just alias it to puss_in_boots_(series) (or whatever might replace it)? Most of it is already tagged with The Last Wish anyway.

create implication sheila_(the_adventures_of_puss_in_boots) -> puss_in_boots_(series)
create implication dulcinea -> puss_in_boots_(series)
create implication pajuna-> puss_in_boots_(series)

I replaced those by suffixed *_(puss_in_boots) tags.

  • 1