Topic: Digital media merge

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #7247 is pending approval.

remove implication digital_drawing_(artwork) (177850) -> digital_media_(artwork) (1294913)
remove implication digital_painting_(artwork) (30311) -> digital_media_(artwork) (1294913)

Reason:

Title

Follow-up:
alias digital_drawing_(artwork) -> digital_media_(artwork)
alias digital_painting_(artwork) -> digital_media_(artwork)

These two tags feel unnecessary, and more importantly, they're confusing. The line between what constitutes a "digital drawing" vs a "digital painting" isn't explicit and I think it results in two tags that are often used when they really don't need to be. There's also the fact that we don't make this distinction for traditional art and in fact have "traditional_drawing_(artwork)" aliased to "traditional_media_(artwork)", which just emphasizes how unnecessary these two tags are.

...People mistag. It happens.

This is a digital drawing:

post #4679030 post #3063511 post #1411608 post #2717800

This is a digital painting:

post #1690001 post #2684588 post #2336917 post #319865

There's always going to be some confusion, but they're pretty clearly distinct things. In digital paintings, you can usually see the strokes.

Though a cleanup and probably a better wiki for both would be a good idea. It can definitely be tricky sometimes especially when digital drawings use a lot of complex shading, I know I've mixed them up.

digital_painting_(media) is also pretty undertagged.

Updated

Watsit

Privileged

nimphia said:
...People mistag. It happens.

[...]

Though a cleanup and probably a better wiki for both would be a good idea. It can definitely be tricky sometimes especially when digital drawings use a lot of complex shading, I know I've mixed them up.

This I think is a good reason to consider it. People mistag, it's difficult to tell apart, and even people aware of the difference can mix them up. From my experience in art sites, digital artists will often use the term "painting" for any rendered digital art, not just digital art that emulates the look of traditional paints. I don't suspect a clearer wiki will stop mistags since it's a term people with experience making digital art use to mean digital artwork, and not realize e6 has a stricter definition.

Updated

  • 1