Shotadonk and lolidonk seemed like pretty useful tags to me (as someone with "loli -lolidonk" and "shota -shotadonk" in their blacklist), so I was curious why they were recently invalidated? I know that lingerie_on_feral and panties_on_feral were also invalidated because you could get similar results from searching "clothed_feral panties" or "clothed_feral lingerie", but I'm not aware of any other tag strings that could serve the same purpose as the now-invalidated donk tags. For instance, searching "shota huge_butt" gives me both shotas with huge butts, and shotas paired with adult characters who have huge butts.

P sure that it's because it's a hyper specific tag, since it only encompasses characters with specific age, gender and ass size. And that those kind of tags are not used here. If you need to have them easily searchable, sets are for that purpose.

rupikonna said:
P sure that it's because it's a hyper specific tag, since it only encompasses characters with specific age, gender and ass size. And that those kind of tags are not used here. If you need to have them easily searchable, sets are for that purpose.

But then, why is oppai_loli and short_stack not invalidated? Shouldn't the same apply to those tags? And having to go to specific sets for big-butted lolis/shotas wouldn't solve the problem of them being hidden from the big-butt tags (and other searches) if I were to go through them with shota and loli on my blacklist.

bltmunch said:
But then, why is oppai_loli and short_stack not invalidated? Shouldn't the same apply to those tags?

Well... there's this aliasing away of oppai_loli.
I don't see why short_stack is mentioned, it is not unnecessarily specific

I agree that the shota/lolidonk tags are overly specific. However, since it sounds like it is something that's rare enough that 'young big_butt' gives mostly false positives, it might be worth tagging big_butt_young or something like that.

snpthecat said:
Well... there's this aliasing away of oppai_loli.
I don't see why short_stack is mentioned, it is not unnecessarily specific

I mention short_stack because the wiki article defines it as specifically applying to "a female character (or female-bodied intersex), with a short, squat body, thick thighs and wide hips." And clarifying on top of that that "while small in stature, and drawn to look 'cute', short stacks are intended to be adult characters." Meaning it wouldn't apply to the shota/loli characters who would've been tagged with shotadonk/lolidonk..

Though, on the topic of oppai_loli being aliased to busty_young, I'm also seeing in this link the suggested aliasing of shotadonk/lolidonk with bottom_heavy_young, which I think would be a good solution.