Topic: Users opinion on MLP content on e621

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

Munkelzahn said:
you made a thread about ponies and thought there wouldn't be drama

I had high hopes. :<

Updated by anonymous

MLP is the #1 blacklisted tag. Pretty much all the active mods are bronies.

This should answer your question.

Updated by anonymous

Gilda_The_Gryphon said:
First post by order:views on 20pc.org:
1189 views
First post by order:views fim here:
117102 views

20pc is dead

We get thousands of people a day :/
besides, compared to e621 the mlp fandom is comparibly dead.
(Compared to e621 the /furry/ fandom is pretty much dead... we have been doing better then FA recently)
EQD doesn't get that many views on topics. :/

redisdead said:
MLP is the #1 blacklisted tag. Pretty much all the active mods are bronies.

This should answer your question.

yes, we get that FIM is the reason you did your take down request, but I thought you left?

Updated by anonymous

Aurali said:
yes, we get that FIM is the reason you did your take down request, but I thought you left?

But if he left, where would he push his agenda?

Updated by anonymous

KodaForShort said:
Juuuust giving my opinion.

You've taken a very selective cross section. Let's take a few things from the front page and analyze (I've omitted porn and closeups)

So what rules can we glean from this wide variety of Pony art?
1) Original characters? No
2) Head design?
a) Fetal-form
b) huge, huge eyes
c) big forehead, circular crainum
d) small nose
e) 3 eyelashes
3) Hooves. What hooves?
4) Wings? I guess those are optional (probably too much detail for some folks)

Ruh bur stamp urh

Considering that you've provided 4 massively different styles, I'd say that you're not exactly helping your case.
On to your garble of letters and numbers points.

1) post #350535 Glowing, gay, rave. Nuff said.

2) post #268196 Head design.

3) I don't even.

4) You've just described 80% of all furry and anime art. Good job.

5) Yes. Because that's how characters are depicted in the show. I don't criticize furry art saying "Tail, furry body."

6) No.

7) Now that you mentioned it, we did need a baseline for the definition of nitpicking.

8) Deeze ones

9) Did you take some bad acid after you posted the first two "identical" pics? If it's a Pegasus ---> wings.

Updated by anonymous

Rocket_Corgi said:
But if he left, where would he push his agenda?

ebay!

Updated by anonymous

I don't hate the show, but I definitely hate the super fanboys bronies, those who say everything will be pony and all that jibber jabber of how great they are, I mean, really? Some of them in their lives have NEVER played a valve game, but just because gaben said he watches MLP they praise him.

About the art, well it varies from artist to artist,sometimes it has an awesome style or has something "original" so to say, and others are just a meme styled screenshot.

but yes, somethimes the amount of pony in this site is overwhelming, once i got 3 pages in a row with only 5 images and i have it set to show 100.

Updated by anonymous

Aurali said:

yes, we get that FIM is the reason you did your take down request, but I thought you left?

I'm still using the site, I just refuse to provide any more free content to you guys. And it wasn't because FIM, even though the drama that ended up with me taking down my stuff was clearly started by bronies.

Updated by anonymous

redisdead said:
I'm still using the site, I just refuse to provide any more free content to you guys. And it wasn't because FIM, even though the drama that ended up with me taking down my stuff was clearly started by bronies.

And to quell the drama you decided to cause more drama. You know, when you add fuel to the fire, the fire stops...[/sarcasm]

Updated by anonymous

Moon_Moon said:
And to quell the drama you decided to cause more drama. You know, when you add fuel to the fire, the fire stops...[/sarcasm]

You actually can fight fire with fire, the way they put out oil well fires is with explosives.
Not really applicable in this case though.

Updated by anonymous

Hammie said:
You actually can fight fire with fire, the way they put out oil well fires is with explosives.
Not really applicable in this case though.

But the explosions snuff out the fire by suffocating it, along with blowing it out with the sonic bewm...it's not the "fire" of the explosion that puts out the fire...

Updated by anonymous

redisdead said:
I'm still using the site, I just refuse to provide any more free content to you guys

redisdead said:
I just refuse to provide any more free content

redisdead said:
free content

You want us to pay to post your content?
post #330159

Updated by anonymous

redisdead said:
I'm still using the site, I just refuse to provide any more free content to you guys. And it wasn't because FIM, even though the drama that ended up with me taking down my stuff was clearly started by bronies.

Refusing to post free content on a free image board? bro, I hope they make a movie based on that story because it was cool as fuck.

Updated by anonymous

Moon_Moon said:
But the explosions snuff out the fire by suffocating it, along with blowing it out with the sonic bewm...it's not the "fire" of the explosion that puts out the fire...

Shockwave, not sonic boom.
Sonic booms are created by an object moving faster than the speed of sound.
Shockwaves in explosions are the actual physical energy of the explosion pushing the air in the area outward from the point of detonation.

I watch too much Discovery channel btw, that's why I know about explosions.

Updated by anonymous

redisdead said:
I'm still using the site, I just refuse to provide any more free content to you guys. And it wasn't because FIM, even though the drama that ended up with me taking down my stuff was clearly started by bronies.

So you pulled the traditional "I'm quiting the fandom" for a week maneuver. I know I know, just one website, but the maneuver was named when people only thought FA existed. Future reference, never make a big deal about leaving, it causes people to turn against you when you come back.

Updated by anonymous

Aurali said:
So you pulled the traditional "I'm quiting the fandom" for a week maneuver. I know I know, just one website, but the maneuver was named when people only thought FA existed. Future reference, never make a big deal about leaving, it causes people to turn against you when you come back.

>Implying I give at least one shit about what adults watching kiddy cartoons think of me.

Actually the reason I showed up here yesterday was that I got a commission done a couple days ago, and I'm checking if someone broke the site's rule again and uploaded it without asking for the permission that I'm not even giving in the first place. Kudos BTW it's been a whole day and it's still not posted, it's gotta be a record.

Then I saw this topic and thought I'd post a funny thing I learned a while back.

Everyone got up on their high horses as if I had some agenda about this site when I don't even want my stuff here. I couldn't care less about how you run this brony shithole as long as takedown requests are handled swiftly.

I don't even give enough shits about that MLP crap to blacklist it, it doesn't even annoy me all that much. Sure I groan whenever I open my usual tag searches and like 98% of the first page is the same boring MLP shit, spreading all over the place like cancer, but I just find the disconnect between admins and the userbase hilarious. That and the fact that you're trying to make watching a kiddy cartoon when you're >12 years old socially acceptable.

Updated by anonymous

I know it's quite out of hand and, to be honest, kinda overrated, but when one starts bashing ANY fandom, let alone MLP, its fans are gonna rage. Which may result in banning from a site.

Really, why can't we all, as a species, just let the other be? Is it really that hard not to go on a crusade to cause butthurt? I mean, in general, not just redisdead. Sure, I don't like scat fetishists, for example. In fact, I wish it didn't exist. Still, I just blacklisted it and left it alone. Simple as.

And, to be fair, it IS a little bit of an overreaction on red's part.

Updated by anonymous

I won't comment your mlp butthurt about which you don't give a shit, and you just can't stop posting how much shit you don't give about it.

I won't comment and obsession whether someone posted your art/characters here or not that, apparently, one of first thoughts after getting comissions is "OMG, they posted it on e621!!!!111".

It's just not worth it.

But I'll comment on one thing:

redisdead said:
That and the fact that you're trying to make watching a kiddy cartoon when you're >12 years old socially acceptable.

I just hope that you are sterile and won't have children in future. It would be awful to be your child.

Updated by anonymous

redisdead said:
Useless dribble

You're on a furry website, bitching about the furry art, and you won't even bother to blacklist it? And the Darwin Award goes to...

Renard_Queenston said:
it IS a little bit of an overreaction on red's part.

Lol, a bit? He pretty much ragequit and took down his mediocre art, and then says that he won't post free art on a free art website. I think he's swinging from the ceiling fan in a frenzied almond-coated rage than overreacting just a little bit.

Updated by anonymous

redguyisred

How did you get ANY of that from what I wrote. I didn't care about your "dislike of bronies" :/ My point was you claim you left, but haven't obviously. Furries have been pulling that stunt for years to garner attention.

redisdead said:
but I just find the disconnect between admins and the userbase hilarious.

Rainbow dash is really the only "brony" admin, this is not a "brony" website, and it's even slowly losing it's furry designation as it becomes more and more a "fantasy porn art site".

Websites are fluid, and people come and go, this is how the world works. "Brony" will die soon, and it will go back to being the same as adventure time, or pokemon or whatever.. I'm surprised it lasted this long. Then something else will come, take it's place, and people will bitch there is too much of that.

Updated by anonymous

Aurali said:
Rainbow dash is really the only "brony" admin, this is not a "brony" website, and it's even slowly losing it's furry designation as it becomes more and more a "fantasy porn art site".

And I'm not even a brony! I don't watch the show or anything of that. I just admin as a certain character from a certain show

Updated by anonymous

Rainbow_Dash said:
And I'm not even a brony! I don't watch the show or anything of that. I just admin as a certain character from a certain show

I suppose I could be the only "brony" admin, but I tend to hide my love of the show outside of the internet.

Updated by anonymous

Rainbow_Dash said:
I don't watch the show or anything of that.

Normally I wouldn't believe you. However after seeing certain, rather highly upvoted, mlp fanfic where the author stated in the comments that he didn't watch a single episode of the show nothing is going to surprise me.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1
  • 2