Topic: Tag Alias: Battle -> Combat

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Hellacious said:
Aliasing Battle -> Combat.

Reason: A battle implies combat, no?

Not necessarily, i think. There is a battle of intellects, but i never heard about combat of intellects.

Updated by anonymous

But (as far as I know) nobody ever uses the battle tag for anything but actual fighting.

Updated by anonymous

This seems like a good candidate for an alias.

com·bat
   /v. kəmˈbæt, ˈkɒmbæt, ˈkʌm-; n. ˈkɒmbæt, ˈkʌm-/
verb, -bat·ed, -bat·ing or ( especially British ) -bat·ted, -bat·ting, noun

–verb (used without object)
2.
to battle; contend: to combat with disease.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/combat

The two also seem to be used interchangeably on the site.

Updated by anonymous

Ghosti said:
Not necessarily, i think. There is a battle of intellects, but i never heard about combat of intellects.

That situation is still a form of combat. Combat isn't necessarily physical, as evidenced by the definition ikdind posted (i.e., contend). At any route, that particular saying is modified by the word "intellect." That's what changes it's meaning. "battle_of_wits," or "battle_of_intellect" would be the proper tag in that situation, not "battle" alone.

But honestly, have you ever seen a an image of two furries playing chess, having a verbal debate or otherwise conflicting with one another in a non-violent manner and thought, "Golly gee! That's a battle of wits! I should tag that!"

Updated by anonymous

  • 1