Topic: *_penetrated tag is useful for filtering

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

recently aliased to invalid. :(

this is a loss of information/tagging signal quality.

female alone in a penetration scene isnt useful to find non-'gay' content (this being a popular example where hetero users dont want to see 'gay' content). Yes im fine with gay content, this isnt a rant against 'teh gay', but just as much as I dont want to see some boring stuff, I dont want to see tentacles (easy to filter!), or content where males are the bottom (hard to filter, why?).

A female or herm penetrating a male has "anal female" tags in it, which might make you think im looking for females being penetrated anally (I am! and for sure a very popular search), and yet there's males getting a feeldoe in the ass, especially when 'strapon' (which a feeldoe isnt, no straps, thus often hidden in the image until clarified by referal to another related post, so inappropriate tag) isnt used.

*_penetrated (female_penetrated, male_penetrated, herm_penetrated, shemale_penetrated, etc) are all useful tags for filtering out images that not able to unsee for some, and a waste of time for all and bandwidth for the site.

Can we turn these into valid tags, since nothing else currently expresses exactly that somewhat important general disctinction that applies to probably 30%+ of the images here?

A test of a tag being useless should demonstrate how other filtering can just as easily filter out all images that do not want to be seen without having to guess at 50 other possibly tags.

Sides, I dont mind seeing females penetrated by other females with strapons or feeldoes - how can I filter out males being penetrated? "-male" doesnt work as it filters out males penetrating females.

So, contrary to the alias, not useless at all. Remove the alias to inappropriate_tag, it's highly useful.

Updated by Riversyde

mat5x said:
A female or herm penetrating a male has "anal female" tags in it, which might make you think im looking for females being penetrated anally (I am! and for sure a very popular search), and yet there's males getting a feeldoe in the ass, especially when 'strapon' (which a feeldoe isnt, no straps, thus often hidden in the image until clarified by referal to another related post, so inappropriate tag) isnt used.

There's already a tag for that, it's "pegging".

Updated by anonymous

Kald

Former Staff

Aurali said:
over tagging is bad tagging :(

Agree, bring an end to redundant tags, all you want can be obtained by some tags combinations.

mat5x said:
content where males are the bottom (hard to filter, why?).

cowgirl_position and reverse_cowgirl_position will take out a lot of them

mat5x said:
A female or herm penetrating a male has "anal female" tags in it, which might make you think im looking for females being penetrated anally (I am! and for sure a very popular search), and yet there's males getting a feeldoe in the ass, especially when 'strapon' (which a feeldoe isnt, no straps, thus often hidden in the image until clarified by referal to another related post, so inappropriate tag) isnt used.

You need to take out "male herm anal", "male dickgirl anal" and "pegging" ; yes the latter is probably undertagged, you it's up to you to make e621 a better place.

Updated by anonymous

Aurali said:
over tagging is bad tagging :(

But better than little tagging. More tags is more specific... as long as it isn't over the top, which I don't see this is. I wouldn't mind seeing this becoming a commonplace tag.

Updated by anonymous

These tags are redundant.

Pegging = male penetrated
Penetration = 9 times out of 10 female penetrated, even before adding -pegging or female
Shemale + Pegging = shemale penetrated
Herm = if you're looking at herm pics you can't possibly tell me the sight of gender specific genitalia going into other genitalia in any combination is somehow offensive to you

It's the same retarded hypserspecific bullshit tags that led to all the stupid "short_red_hair" "long_red_hair" etc hair tags. I loathe these stupid hair tags. Is it too fucking hard to filter by "long/short hair" and "colour hair"?

Updated by anonymous

Kald

Former Staff

mellis said:
It's the same retarded hypserspecific bullshit tags that led to all the stupid "short_red_hair" "long_red_hair" etc hair tags. I loathe these stupid hair tags. Is it too fucking hard to filter by "long/short hair" and "colour hair"?

I'm glad to see i'm not the only one who thinks that. None use these tags, they're only the fucking results of danbooru/gelbooru tags copy/pasting.

Updated by anonymous

search "anal_penetration -pegging -intersex"

all females getting fucked by males in the butt :)

Updated by anonymous

  • 1