So I tried to delete the tag "canine" from a post I uploaded not long ago of a fox, but it won't let me. What gives? Foxes are NOT canine. Is there some kind of autotag thing going on or something?
Updated by Anomynous
Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions
So I tried to delete the tag "canine" from a post I uploaded not long ago of a fox, but it won't let me. What gives? Foxes are NOT canine. Is there some kind of autotag thing going on or something?
Updated by Anomynous
It's a tag implication, yes: see http://e621.net/tag_implication?query=canine
Foxes are definitely canine, though (members of the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canidae family), so the implication should be fine.
Updated by anonymous
cetetic said:
It's a tag implication, yes: see http://e621.net/tag_implication?query=canineFoxes are [...] (members of the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canidae family), so the implication should be fine.
Shouldn't that be 'Canid' rather than 'Canine' ('Vulpine' is OK though) to be more taxonomically correct?
It might at least avoid a bit of confusion.
Updated by anonymous
No, "canine" (subfamily Caninae) includes foxes (Vulpis) and all other living canids.
(There used to be non-canine canids, but they're all extinct - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canidae#Eocene_epoch - hence "canid" and "canine" are generally synonyms outside of paleontology.)
Updated by anonymous
cetetic said:
(There used to be non-canine canids, but they're all extinct - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canidae#Eocene_epoch - hence "canid" and "canine" are generally synonyms outside of paleontology.)
Ah, enlightenment.
Updated by anonymous
Yeah, "canine" is a bit incorrect in the common usage, and a bit loose in the scientific one. I'm more in favour of the common usage, and not using funky derived words like "equid", or "canid"; I'd quite like people to be able to tag without an advanced knowledge of scientific Greek or Latin :(
Quick Q: is an "equine" in Equini or Equinae, Equus or Equidae? Quick A: it doesn't matter. Horsecock.
There's a case for using canine/feline for "looks like a dog/cat but I'm not sure which one", and not faffing around with domestic_dog or domestic_cat to cover the corner case.
Updated by anonymous