Series: Nightmare's new toy.

Twilight finds herself in the Nightmares clutches.

Blacklisted
(help)
anthro bdsm bit_gag bondage bondage_furniture bound bridle candle chain chained clothed clothed/nude clothing collar dildo dungeon duo equid equine female female/female fire forced friendship_is_magic gag genital_torture gloves handwear hasbro hooves horn horn_sheaths latex latex_clothing latex_gloves latex_handwear mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_fetish nipple_pinch nipple_play nude partially_clothed penetration pinch quakehoof rape saint_andrew's_cross scroll sex_toy spiked_dildo spiked_sex_toy spikes spread_eagle submissive submissive_female torture twilight_sparkle_(mlp) unguligrade unicorn vaginal vaginal_penetration winged_unicorn wings
↑52♥141C0E
3:4 anthro bdsm bit_gag bondage bound breasts bridle candle chain chained dungeon equid equine female forced friendship_is_magic gag genital_torture hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring jewelry mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nipple_clamp nipple_fetish nipple_play nipples nude penetration piledriver_position pussy_torture quakehoof rape ring_(jewelry) sex solo torture twilight_sparkle_(mlp) vaginal vaginal_penetration wax_torture winged_unicorn wings
↑93♥222C0E
anthro bdsm bit_gag bondage bound bridle candle chain chained choker clothed clothed/nude clothing cuff_(restraint) dungeon duo equid equine female female/female friendship_is_magic gag hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring jewelry mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology necklace nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_fetish nipple_play nipple_weights nipples nude quakehoof restraints ring_(jewelry) shackles spiked_choker spiked_stockings suspension suspension_bondage temperature_play torture twilight_sparkle_(mlp) winged_unicorn wings
↑50♥102C0Q
all_fours anal anal_hook anal_penetration anthro bdsm bit_gag bound breasts bridle castle chain chained clothed clothed/nude clothed_female clothing collar crawling duo equid equine female female/female flogger friendship_is_magic gag hanging_breasts hasbro hook_penetration horn horn_jewelry horn_ring jewelry legwear looking_back mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nude penetration petplay princess_celestia_(mlp) quakehoof ring_(jewelry) roleplay stained_glass thigh_highs twilight_sparkle_(mlp) winged_unicorn wings
↑45♥86C0E
all_fours alternate_species anal anal_hook anal_penetration anthro arthropod bat_pony bdsm big_macintosh_(mlp) bit_gag bondage bound breasts bridle butt chain chain_leash changeling chastity_cage chastity_device clothed clothed/nude clothing collar cuff_(restraint) earth_pony equid equine female friendship_is_magic gag genitals group hair hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring horse indirect_incest_(lore) jewelry king_sombra_(mlp) kneeling leash leash_pull male mammal muzzle_(object) muzzled my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_piercing nipples nude panties penetration petplay piercing pony ponyplay princess_cadance_(mlp) princess_celestia_(mlp) pussy quakehoof queen_chrysalis_(mlp) restraints ring_(jewelry) roleplay shining_armor_(mlp) slave stained_glass twilight_sparkle_(mlp) underwear unicorn winged_unicorn wings wrist_cuffs zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑88♥212C1E
16:9 anthro anthrofied armwear bdsm bent_over big_breasts blue_eyes bondage bound breasts clothed clothed/nude clothing cutie_mark dildo duo elbow_gloves equid equine feathered_wings feathers female female/female fluttershy_(mlp) forced friendship_is_magic gloves hand_on_butt handwear hanging_breasts hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring incest_(lore) jewelry looking_back mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology navel nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_piercing nipple_weights nipples nude piercing princess_celestia_(mlp) purple_eyes quakehoof rape restrained restraints ring_(jewelry) sex_toy spreader_bar stained_glass stocks strapon twilight_sparkle_(mlp) widescreen winged_unicorn wings wings_tied
↑62♥121C2E
anal anal_penetration animal_genitalia animal_penis anthro arms_above_head ball_gag bdsm bondage bound bound_together bridle chain chained cunnilingus curtains dildo dildo_sitting duo equid equine equine_genitalia equine_penis erection female forced forced_partners friendship_is_magic gag genitals hands_behind_back hasbro hi_res horn kneeling kneeling_oral_position linked_nipples linked_piercing looking_at_another looking_away male male/female mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nipple_fetish nipple_piercing nipple_play nipple_ring nipple_ring_pull nipple_to_gag nipples nude oral penetration penis piercing princess_cadance_(mlp) quakehoof ring_piercing sex sex_toy shining_armor_(mlp) spread_legs spreading submissive submissive_male unicorn vaginal winged_unicorn wings
↑63♥147C0E
anal anal_penetration anthro bdsm bit_gag blinders bondage bound bridle candle collar ear_piercing ear_ring equid equine eyewear female fire forced friendship_is_magic gag hasbro heat_(temperature) hi_res kneeling mammal my_little_pony navel nipple_chain nipple_fetish nipple_piercing nipple_play nipples nude penetration petplay piercing ponyplay quakehoof rape ring_piercing roleplay solo vaginal vaginal_penetration wax_play zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑52♥118C0E
absurd_res anal anal_penetration animal_genitalia animal_penis anthro arthropod bdsm black_penis bondage bound bound_together candle chain chained changeling cobondage collar collar_to_collar dildo dildo_in_ass dildo_insertion dildo_sitting duo equid equine equine_genitalia equine_penis erection eye_contact friendship_is_magic fur genitals green_penis grey_body grey_fur gynomorph hasbro hi_res hooves horn horn_jewelry horn_ring intersex intersex/male jewelry king_sombra_(mlp) leash leashed_collar leashed_together linked_collars linked_nipples linked_penises linked_piercing looking_at_another machine male mammal muzzle_(object) muzzled my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nipple_fetish nipple_piercing nipple_play nipples nude object_in_ass penetration penis piercing quakehoof queen_chrysalis_(mlp) ridged_penis ring_(jewelry) rope sex_toy sex_toy_in_ass sex_toy_insertion struggling tapering_penis unguligrade unicorn vein veiny_penis
↑61♥114C0E
all_fours anal anal_penetration anthro bdsm big_breasts bit_gag bondage bound breasts bridle buttplug dildo dildo_sitting double_anal double_penetration equid equine female female/female forced forced_partners friendship_is_magic gag group hanging_breasts hasbro hi_res horn horn_grab horn_jewelry horn_ring incest_(lore) jewelry kneeling_oral_position mammal my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_chain nipple_fetish nipple_play penetration petplay plug_(sex_toy) ponyplay princess_cadance_(mlp) princess_celestia_(mlp) pseudo_incest_(lore) quakehoof rape reins ring_(jewelry) roleplay sex_toy throne_room twilight_sparkle_(mlp) vaginal vaginal_penetration wine_bottle winged_unicorn wings wings_tied zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑98♥176C0E
16:9 anal anal_penetration anthro areola arms_above_head arthropod ball_gag bdsm big_breasts bondage bound bound_together breasts chain chained changeling dominant dominant_female dungeon equid equine erection female friendship_is_magic gag group hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring jewelry king_sombra_(mlp) kneeling_oral_position looking_away male male/female male_penetrated mammal medium_breasts my_little_pony my_little_pony:_the_movie_(2017) mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nipple_clamp nipples nude object_in_ass pegasus pegging penetration quakehoof queen_chrysalis_(mlp) rainbow_dash_(mlp) ring_(jewelry) sex sex_toy sex_toy_in_ass sex_toy_insertion sex_toy_penetration shining_armor_(mlp) spitfire_(mlp) tapestry tempest_shadow_(mlp) toying_partner unicorn_horn upside_down widescreen wings wonderbolts_(mlp)
↑41♥67C0E
anthro areola bdsm big_breasts bit_gag breasts bridle candle_holder castle chandelier clothed clothed/nude clothing collar crescent_moon duo equid equine female friendship_is_magic gag genitals harness hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring jewelry maid_uniform mammal medium_breasts moon my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nipple_chain nipple_clamp_pull nipple_fetish nipple_play nude petplay ponyplay pussy quakehoof rarity_(mlp) ring_(jewelry) roleplay skimpy_dress twilight_sparkle_(mlp) unicorn uniform winged_unicorn wings
↑19♥50C0E
16:9 anal anal_penetration anthro ball_gag bdsm blindfold bondage bound buttplug buttplug_in_ass buttplug_insertion dildo dildo_in_pussy dildo_insertion equid equine female fluttershy_(mlp) friendship_is_magic gag gem group harness hasbro hi_res horn jewel_buttplug looking_at_another mammal my_little_pony my_little_pony:_the_movie_(2017) mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_fetish nipple_play nipples nude object_in_ass pegasus penetration petplay plug_(sex_toy) plug_insertion ponyplay quakehoof rainbow_dash_(mlp) rarity_(mlp) roleplay sex_toy sex_toy_in_ass sex_toy_in_pussy sex_toy_insertion starlight_glimmer_(mlp) tempest_shadow_(mlp) twilight_sparkle_(mlp) unicorn vaginal vaginal_penetration widescreen winged_unicorn wings zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑35♥78C0E
anthro bdsm bondage bound breast_grab breasts cuff_(restraint) equid equine female friendship_is_magic group hand_on_breast hasbro hi_res horn horn_jewelry horn_ring incest_(lore) jewelry kneeling mammal masturbation my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology navel nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipples nude princess_celestia_(mlp) quakehoof restraints ring_(jewelry) silhouette spread_wings stained_glass winged_unicorn wings
↑23♥58C0E
anthro bdsm bed big_breasts bit_gag blinders bondage bound breasts bridle duo equid equine eyewear female friendship_is_magic furniture gag grin hanging_breasts harness hasbro hi_res horn lamp lantern mammal masturbation my_little_pony mythological_creature mythological_equine mythology nightmare_moon_(mlp) nipple_fetish nipple_play nipples nude petplay ponyplay quakehoof roleplay smile suspension suspension_bondage winged_unicorn wings zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑22♥58C0E
anthro bdsm bit_gag blindfold bondage bound breasts equid equine female flower forniphilia friendship_is_magic gag hanging_breasts harness hasbro hi_res mammal my_little_pony nude penetration plant quakehoof solo upside_down vaginal vaginal_penetration zebra zecora_(mlp)
↑25♥66C0E
  • 1