Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions
Implicating musclegut → belly
Link to implication
A belly needs to be visible for musclegut to apply and the larger belly sizes imply the smaller ones, so musclegut would end up with the belly tag anyway.
EDIT: The tag implication musclegut -> belly (forum #190595) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.
Updated by auto moderator
Personally, I think the musclegut tag should be done away with; one cannot have visible abs with a big_belly. While overweight muscular characters may be thing (insert here: festish), methinks the tag description is inherently contradictory.
+1 to invalidate musclegut, or posibly to alias it to belly.
(perhaps alias to the horrid tag musclechub to allow for blacklist functionality)
Updated by anonymous
Qmannn said:
Gut does not mean the same thing as abs ...
Obviously, as they are mutually exclusive (insofar as visible tagging). This is why I think the tag should be aliased or removed.
Qmannn said:
Also, not all characters with a belly are overweight nor is the belly always big as far as the wiki is concerned.
True, yet the improper utilization of slightly_chubby has been brought up many times here, and a 'visible belly' pretty much conveys being overweight, even if only by a small degree (ie. not necessarily obese ).
I am likely fighting an uphill battle here, as musclegut is a popular tag; it frustrates me that such a contradictory tag exists.
Having said that, I think an alias to belly would be more appropriate, or even an alias to musclechub, as it simplifies searches (or blacklists) for a certain body typology (and does not imply a big gut as being 'muscular').
Updated by anonymous
Sharp_Coyote said:
Personally, I think the musclegut tag should be done away with; one cannot have visible abs with a big_belly. While overweight muscular characters may be thing (insert here: festish), methinks the tag description is inherently contradictory.+1 to invalidate musclegut, or posibly to alias it to belly.
(perhaps alias to the horrid tag musclechub to allow for blacklist functionality)
Obviously, as they are mutually exclusive (insofar as visible tagging). This is why I think the tag should be aliased or removed.
I am likely fighting an uphill battle here, as musclegut is a popular tag; it frustrates me that such a contradictory tag exists.
Genuinely curious about why you'd want to invalidate a tag that you (seem to) dislike/have blacklisted
Does it conflict with other tags in an active way?
-
Having said that, I think an alias to belly would be more appropriate,
How would you find relevant content with an alias to belly though,
overweight ~muscular ~abs?
-
or even an alias to musclechub, as it simplifies searches (or blacklists) for a certain body typology (and does not imply a big gut as being 'muscular').
An alias of musclegut \<\-\> musclechub may work,
can't really say I know much about tags like these
-
True, yet the improper utilization of slightly_chubby has been brought up many times here, and a 'visible belly' pretty much conveys being overweight, even if only by a small degree (ie. not necessarily obese ).
Agreed
This seems to be more of an issue with the tag definitions, rather than people them using them 'wrongly' though
Can someone who knows more about these tags explain the difference between
currently tagged with musclegut
and
neither tagged with abs nor muscular
?
-
Would this count? post #304362
Updated by anonymous
Related discussion:
forum #189422 - Tagging Slim vs. Skinny (Apr. 2016)
Updated by anonymous
The tag implication musclegut -> belly (forum #190595) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.
