Topic: Tag Implication: tentacle_impalement -> all_the_way_through

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Dyrone

Blocked

-1 to all of these x_impalement tags and their proposed implications (and in the future please group them all into a single thread instead of making three). Here is the definition of "impale":

1. pierce or transfix with a sharp instrument.

Now lets compare that definition to the image you yourself just barely tagged as an example of tentacle_impalement:

post #597315

Is she pierced? Well that depends on how loosely you wish to use the term, but I'm going to say in a literal sense no she is not. Is she transfixed? No...she is clearly sitting on the ground. Is the tentacle a "sharp instrument"...uh...no.

Furthermore all_the_way_through means coming in and out of preexisting holes...whereas you can be impaled in a hundred different ways...through the stomach being one of the more popular examples from TV and Film...that wouldn't align well with all_the_way_through. A difference should be maintained between those two tags because those searching for ATWT might not be up for the more grotesque images contained within the impalement tag.

So...yeah...I understand what you are trying to go for with such a tag, but in its current form it's just poorly worded, but even if the wording was changed I don't think we need it. A simple search of tentacle and all_the_way_through is going to garner pretty much the exact same results as that tag would.

EDIT: And I understand that real porn throws around the term "impale" a lot...I mean...I can't count how number of videos that have some variation of the title "tiny chick IMPALED by massive cock!" But the difference between drawn porn and real porn is that impalement can actually be a thing in drawn porn. So we can't go throwing around the word as easily because you can't assume the term is always going to be used as hyperbole in the realm of drawn porn.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1