Implicating anal_orgasm → orgasm
Link to implication

Reason:

This is still defined as an orgasm.

EDIT: The tag implication anal_orgasm -> orgasm (forum #276324) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.

1-

I'm thinking alias to invalid. What's the point of this tag?
Searching anal & orgasm will give you the same results.

Cane751 said:
1-

I'm thinking alias to invalid. What's the point of this tag?
Searching anal & orgasm will give you the same results.

No. searching anal and orgasm covers also literally all images where character A cums in character B's ass, and any scenarios where anal stuff is going on, and character cums from direct penile stimulation, and huge chunk of group sex pictures. Anal_orgasm is when character has an orgasm when someone is doing something to their ass.

hiekkapillu said:
Anal_orgasm is when character has an orgasm when someone is doing something to their ass.

This sounds like some sort of penetration. Those tags already exist.

I don't like the name of the anal_orgasm tag. Usually it's the genitals which are shown having the actual orgasm, because that's not really a function of the anus. We wouldn't call it a boob orgasm if someone climaxed when their breasts were stimulated, or a mouth orgasm if someone climaxed while performing oral sex.

I think the hands-free tag is more appropriate for this sort of thing. But then, I defer to those who might be more invested in this, given I tend to avoid the anal tag mostly. I just wanted to express what thoughts I had.

Cane751 said:
1-

I'm thinking alias to invalid. What's the point of this tag?
Searching anal & orgasm will give you the same results.

Having an orgasm during anal sex is not the same as having an anal orgasm. They are achieved through very different means and—speaking from experience—are very different sensations.

These are pics one would tag "anal" and "orgasm":
post #1688266
post #176877

These are pics to be tagged "anal_orgasm":
post #1945978
post #1642178

You can really tell the difference in a well-drawn pic. It's one of my favorite tags; let's leave it be.

Clawdragons said:
I don't like the name of the anal_orgasm tag. Usually it's the genitals which are shown having the actual orgasm, because that's not really a function of the anus. We wouldn't call it a boob orgasm if someone climaxed when their breasts were stimulated, or a mouth orgasm if someone climaxed while performing oral sex.

I think the hands-free tag is more appropriate for this sort of thing. But then, I defer to those who might be more invested in this, given I tend to avoid the anal tag mostly. I just wanted to express what thoughts I had.

I can't think of any better name for it. Prostate_orgasm wouldn't fit because it's also accomplished through g-spot stimulation, and g-spot_orgasm includes those caused through vaginal stimulation. Hands-free, likewise, goes for anything from anal stimulation to electrostim to spontaneous orgasms. The only common denominator is anal penetration, and we can't just change the name of anal sex all willy-nilly.

Adda_le_Blue said:
These are pics to be tagged "anal_orgasm":
post #1945978
post #1642178

These aren't good examples. It's just anal combined with looking pleasured and/or orgasm.

Cane751 said:
These aren't good examples. It's just anal combined with looking pleasured and/or orgasm.

Are you missing the whole part where the characters are having an orgasm from anal stimulation alone?

Cane751 said:
These aren't good examples. It's just anal combined with looking pleasured and/or orgasm.

That's just why I picked those ones! They're both unmistakably anal and unmistakably earth-shattering orgasms, and neither has a hint of penile or vaginal stimulation. What more do we need? Neither an anal looking_pleasured search nor an anal orgasm search would give us the results we're hoping to find under anal_orgasm. Having the tag hurts no one and helps those who know what it's about.

hiekkapillu said:
Are you missing the whole part where the characters are having an orgasm from anal stimulation alone?

Yeah, stop that.

I don't know how anal_orgasm parses in other languages, but it doesn't sound comparable to something like a penile/vaginal orgasm (if we had the tags) or climaxes/ejaculation in general. I'm willing to admit I'm wrong but an orgasm from anal stimulation is not the first impression I got. I can understand where confusion might arise.

I'm very conflicted about what to do here. It sounds like a good idea. Saves us the trouble of having to search hands-free + anal or other combinations.

But I'm still not entirely sold.

I guess this is where I get contriversal and say:

orgasm is not the same thing as ejaculation.

.
It is possible for men to get anal orgasm or prostate orgasm from something like prostate_stimulator or other kind of direct prostate_stimulation. I think there's videos of this on pornsites, guys just squirming, moaning and throbbing for hour without cum, but can't link real life porn here. Aneros is biggest brand you can use for searching.

In real life some are not able to achieve this and even more are not even aware that it's possible, so it's understandable to think that males aren't aroused if they aren't erect or haven't finished without cumshot.

If we tagged only based on ejaculation, then it would simply be just hands-free. Now the only problem is that when exactly it is determined when male has orgasm on visible based tagging system? Because then we do also have dry_orgasm, which fits the description but isn't exactly the same thing as that's generally used for pre-puberty orgasms from penile stimuli or ruined orgasm, where prostate orgasm is from fiddling with prostate.

So I would either alias this tag to hands-free if that's how it's being used or disambig it so handsfree, dry orgasm, prostate orgasm, cum_in_ass, etc. are properly tagged as "anal orgasm" is way too broad term to know how people will actually use it.

Mairo said:
much of note, perhaps too much to quote in its entirety

Sure, male anal orgasms are—for obvious reasons—more noticeably different from female anal orgasms, but some women find anal orgasms much more intense and enjoyable than the usual fare just as some men do. How would these tag changes affect art depicting a woman's climax? I feel that the hands-free tag doesn't fit our side of things.

Adda_le_Blue said:
Sure, male anal orgasms are—for obvious reasons—more noticeably different from female anal orgasms, but some women find anal orgasms much more intense and enjoyable than the usual fare just as some men do. How would these tag changes affect art depicting a woman's climax? I feel that the hands-free tag doesn't fit our side of things.

Is there a tag that despicts a woman orgasm without direct stimulation? I tend to see hands_free used as a term for any sort of orgasm without direct contact with the genitals. Including females.

In my experience, most of the time that I see an anal_orgasm tag, it seems like the person missed a cum_from_ass or a cum_splatter tag, because there are fluids either seeping from or violently being thrown away from the anus. Based on the last time I'd read the wiki page, it seems like it is intended to be for orgasms where there is visible "splatter" but it is anal_juices, Lube, or some other ambiguous_fluids, and specifically not cum.

If the real intent is to use it for an orgasm from only anal stimulation, then hands-free seems to be the far superior, with some possible looking_pleasured-type tags for non-ejaculating orgasms.

That said, because it's wording seems to get misinterpreted so much, I'd be more in favor of changing anal_orgasm to something a little more specific like orgasm_from_anal. We already have an orgasm_from_oral tag for characters that cum from giving oral without touching themselves, so perhaps this would give us some better usage of the tag.

The tag implication anal_orgasm -> orgasm (forum #276324) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.