The bulk update request #369 has been rejected.

Reason: More meandering meme messes!

• Partially derived from missed aliases/implications on topic #24980.
• As a side note, I noticed 30minchallenge still appears when searching in the 'Tags' area, even though it is currently aliased to 30_minute_art_challenge. (as seen here)

Edit:

• Replaced the alias owo_what's_this -> owo_whats_this to now update the alias to be owo_whats_this -> owo_what's_this. Edited the alias owo_what_is_this to also reflect this.

Edit 2:

• Added request to re-categorize inktober/iron_artist as Invalid category tags. Also added request to re-categorize 30_minute_art_challenge as a Meta category tag.
• Added several more meme implications.

Edit 3:

• Altered the re-categorize request for 30_minute_art_challenge to now be re-categorized as an Invalid category tag.
• Added the implication math_lady -> meme.

EDIT: The bulk update request #369 (forum #299159) has been rejected by @Millcore.

I'm not sure about 30_minute_art_challenge and related. Do we need a tag that means 'I made this in 30 minutes'? That's not something that has a visual element, just a self-imposed time limit on making it, so it seems like something that should be invalidated.

Also,
owo_what's_this -> owo_whats_this
removes an apostrophe while
and_thats_terrible -> and_that's_terrible
adds one. Should tags prefer having an apostrophe?

I'll keep the aliases for 30_minute_art_challenge so that there aren't multiple tags for the same thing.

Though it would be a good discussion on whether or not 30_minute_art_challenge should count as a meme tag, and whether or not 30_minute_art_challenge should be kept at all.

I think I input owo_whats_this that way since owo_whats_this is currently implicated to meme. I can update this to correct the missing apostrophe.

d.d.m. said:
Though it would be a good discussion on whether or not 30_minute_art_challenge should count as a meme tag, and whether or not 30_minute_art_challenge should be kept at all.

Similar for tags like iron_artist and inktober. It just specifies conditions the image was made under, nothing about the image itself or its contents.

There's also the possibility of re-categorizing those tags as Meta category tags. I'm not familiar with iron_artist, but inktober and 30_minute_art_challenge seem to fall in line with how the Meta tag category is often utilized.

d.d.m. said:
I'm not familiar with iron_artist, but inktober and 30_minute_art_challenge seem to fall in line with how the Meta tag category is often utilized.

Originally, Iron Artist meant making 100 pictures in a month (a play on the Iron Chef challenge, to make a good meal in a short amount of time). However, I'm not sure if its meaning has shifted over time to mean something else, from people not understanding its original goal.

With that in mind, I definitely see issues with tagging iron_artist consistently. Would it refer to only the 100th post or to all of the 100 posts created as part of the iron_artist challenge? Furthermore, there could be confusion and mistagging if an artist decided to use the name 'iron'.

d.d.m. said:
With that in mind, I definitely see issues with tagging iron_artist consistently. Would it refer to only the 100th post or to all of the 100 posts created as part of the iron_artist challenge? Furthermore, there could be confusion and mistagging if an artist decided to use the name 'iron'.

Honestly, that sounds like something that belongs to pools or something, rather than having a tag for it. Especially if, as you pointed out, an artist might potentially use "iron" as a name.

vulkalu said:
Honestly, that sounds like something that belongs to pools or something, rather than having a tag for it. Especially if, as you pointed out, an artist might potentially use "iron" as a name.

Yeah, utilizing the Sets or Pools would probably be better for the posts currently tagged with iron_artist (after looking through inktober, it seems like the same applies to this tag). Hopefully someone can reorganize the iron_artist and inktober posts into Sets or Pools, but I'll edit the BUR to re-categorize iron_artist and inktober as Invalid category tags.

I'll also edit the BUR to re-categorize 30_minute_art_challenge as a Meta category tag, unless folks feel differently about that.

Since the votes cast on this BUR remain solidly neutral, I'm wondering if folks would prefer 30_minute_art_challenge be re-categorized as an Invalid category tag (or if any other edits should be made to this BUR).

I've updated the BUR to now re-categorize 30_minute_art_challenge as an Invalid category tag, as well as adding the implication math_lady -> meme.
post #1277831

The bulk update request #369 (forum #299159) has been rejected by @Millcore.

I just don't know what went wrong...
post #1425899
Should I try resubmitting this? I made several edits to this BUR, though I never got any feedback about these edits.