I recently uploaded post #2639535 and tagged both Braxia and Walter Sache, because Braxia redrew post #335195. Is that proper tagging?

Yeah, it is still considered an edit if the artist retraced an original work. So, both artists get tagged in this case.

We don't allow traced artwork, so while technically both artists were "responsible" for the creation the image itself is simply not allowed here.

notmenotyou said:
We don't allow traced artwork, so while technically both artists were "responsible" for the creation the image itself is simply not allowed here.

Oh come on! Why is that not allowed?

ijustwantupdates said:
Oh come on! Why is that not allowed?

Blatant traces are generally seen as disrespectful to artists, often (but not always) go uncredited, and are generally not worth archiving.
Even if e6 were to allow traces: do we allow unlimited traced copies of the same image? If not, which ones take priority?

lafcadio said:
Blatant traces are generally seen as disrespectful to artists, often (but not always) go uncredited, and are generally not worth archiving.
Even if e6 were to allow traces: do we allow unlimited traced copies of the same image? If not, which ones take priority?

Well, in the original description of the image I uploaded, Braxia DID credit Walter Sasche. Does that change anything?

ijustwantupdates said:
Well, in the original description of the image I uploaded, Braxia DID credit Walter Sasche. Does that change anything?

Considering you ignored every other point I put forward, no.