Topic: [APPROVED] Tag alias: arrow -> arrow_(disambiguation)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The tag alias #53164 arrow -> arrow_(disambiguation) has been approved.

Reason: arrow wiki for weapon arrow, but some posts tagged with arrow show directional_arrow instead.

Maybe disambiguate arrow into arrow_(weapon) (already has 11 posts) and directional_arrow?

(there is forum topic https://e621.net/forum_topics/25029 (with Siral Exan and D.D.M. giving a +1 to disambiguation), but it doesn't seem to have resulted in an alias suggestion at https://e621.net/tag_aliases )

arrow posts that should be tagged with directional_arrow instead:
1) post #2860022
2&3) post #2857286 and post #2857280
4) post #2855078

5-9) post #2835395 (and others in pool #24716 )(five posts)
10&11) post #2835115 and post #2830063
12) post #2826085

13&14) post #2813297 and post #2813288
15) post #2811778
16) post #2802591

17) post #2800033
18) 2787709 (so nsfw i don't want to thumbnail it)
19) post #2786266

20) post #2783948
21) post #2779185
22) post #2776159 (didn't notice any weapon arrows ... i think arrow tag for the directional_arrow on aang's head)

23) post #2772141
24) post #2765487
25) post #2763593

26) post #2760016
27) post #2755457

Those 27 were from the 75 latest of arrow -bow_(weapon)

if rest of arrow has same ratio of mistagging that would be ...

(math mode engaged)

total number of arrow -bow_(weapon) posts is = (15*75)+39 = 1164 posts

1164 posts * (27/75) = 419.04 = maybe 419 posts miss-tagged.

EDIT: The tag alias arrow -> arrow_(disambiguation) (forum #314336) has been approved by @bitWolfy.

Updated by auto moderator

arrow* character tags:
1) 16 . . . arrow_(amberreaper)
2) 6 . . . arrow_(arrow_k9)
3) 1 . . . arrow_(arrowolga)
4) 11 . . . arrow_(arrowstorm)
5) 9 . . . arrow_(character)
6) 1 . . . arrow_(fullmoonarrow)
7) 1 . . . arrow_(rudolph)
8) 26 . . . arrow_(scuzzyfox)
9) 1 . . . arrow_the_dog
10) 1 . . . arrow_the_kobold
11) 1 . . . arrow_the_leafy_sea_dragon
12) 4 . . . arrow_drake_(character) (probably charater of artist below)

?) 2 . . . arrowstorm (possibly same as arrow_(arrowstorm) above)
(EDIT: uploads tagged with arrowstorm depicted arrowsmith's character Arrow)

some arrow* artist tags:
6 . . . arrow_drake
6 . . . arrow_k9
1 . . . arrow_owlet

45 . . . arrowdark
12 . . . arrowheadx

Updated

The bulk update request #2096 is active.

create alias arrow_(character) (0) -> arrow_(disambiguation) (1)

Reason: There are several characters named arrow, so arrow_(character) is just as ambiguous as the plain arrow tag. The arrow (disambiguation) wiki already lists all the “arrow” characters, so it makes sense to redirect people there. Not to mention, arrow_(character)_(disambiguation) is a needlessly wordy tag.

EDIT: The bulk update request #2096 (forum #328503) has been approved by @bitWolfy.

Updated by auto moderator

  • 1