Topic: [REJECTED] Sonic R

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #4117 has been rejected.

remove alias sonic_r (0) -> sonic_the_hedgehog_(series) (113941)
remove implication tails_doll (251) -> sonic_the_hedgehog_(series) (113941)

Reason: Similar to other games with unique characters like sonic_shuffle, since Tails Doll is only in Sonic R, it should imply Sonic R, and Sonic R shouldn't be aliased.

Part 2:

create implication sonic_r -> sonic_the_hedgehog_(series)
create implication tails_doll -> sonic_r

EDIT: The bulk update request #4117 (forum #357247) has been rejected by @naughtyclaws.

Updated by auto moderator

A particular game in a series having unique characters isn't enough to warrant the game having its own tag. You can still search for those characters just fine. There are plenty of games/shows/comics/etc with unique characters that are still aliased to the series tag if that entry isn't unique enough to warrant a distinct tag.

watsit said:
A particular game in a series having unique characters isn't enough to warrant the game having its own tag. You can still search for those characters just fine. There are plenty of games/shows/comics/etc with unique characters that are still aliased to the series tag if that entry isn't unique enough to warrant a distinct tag.

That's fine then. I don't understand why some Sonic games get tags and others don't, though? It makes no sense. Why is sonic_shuffle, sonic_forces, etc. a tag, if others get aliased away? I personally don't mind if they get aliased, but I think they should be consistent at least, though I think things like sonic_adventure, sonic_riders and sonic_frontiers are fine to stay separate.Especially with Shuffle, I don't get how it's unique enough but R isn't. They're both spinoffs in different genres.And all Forces really has going for it is that Infinite and the custom character come from it.We also have things like kirby_and_the_forgotten_land. FNAF also has literally every game unaliased.

Just gonna reject this one for now.

Updated

  • 1