Topic: what to do with mataki* tags? (disambiguate?)

Posted under Tag/Wiki Projects and Questions

Wondering what to do with mataki* tags.
(Mainly what artist tag to use for art by FA/mataki23.)

mataki tag a mix of:
1) art by artist with FA username mataki23
2) a character of https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki (edit: wolf character apparently named Mataki)

Plus FA/mataki23 has a character named Mataki.
{ https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki23/ includes "...
My fursona - Mataki ..." }

alias mataki TO mataki_(disambiguation)?

***

Checked history of mataki tag
https://e621.net/tag_type_versions?search%5Btag%5D=mataki
and apparently it has been character tag since the beginning (of the tag).

I noticed artwork post #2816404 had no artist tag, and 3 character tags (but only 2 characters in image).
History of that post (2816404):
1) uploaded by user Mataki https://e621.net/users/701330 (back in 2021 July)
with character tag mataki
2) I changed tag from mataki (character tag) to mataki23 (artist tag)
(because artist's FA is https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki23/ and mataki23 is existing artist tag.)
(artist's FA upload at https://www.furaffinity.net/view/42629114 )

*
One other post (post #2606153 ) had mataki tag removed. Tag history of this post:
1) 2021 February: uploaded with character tag mataki (uploaded by someone who is presumably not the artist)
2) 2021 November: mataki tag replaced with unknown_artist tag (probably because the only source in source field at the time now deleted from FA)
3) 2021 December: unknown_artist tag replaced with mataki23 tag.

***
e621 user Mataki has uploaded 14 posts (art all apparently by FA/Mataki23):

A) currently NO artist tag, with mataki character tag:
a1-4) post #2989776 , post #2977371 , post #2962687, & post #2849497
a5-8) post #2829713 , post #2801039 , post #2799572 , & post #2798090

B) NO artist tag, nor any mataki* tag:
b1) post #2797980 (but has "Mataki '21" on art)

C) both mataki23 and mataki tags:
c1) post #2970407
c2) post #2947153

D) mataki23 tags:
d1) post #2861037 (I changed tag from mataki TO mataki23)
d2) post #2816404 , already mention earlier (I changed tag from mataki TO mataki23)

E) post #2802613 tagged with artist tag ferric (and character tag mataki), but in FA/mataki23 gallery and apparently by mataki23 ("Mataki 2021" on art)

***

Looking through FA/mataki23 gallery for names on art (ignoring the scraps gallery):
1) oldest upload has "karomataki" on it
FA mataki23: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/22115648/ "Commission [old artwork]"
DA KaroMataki: https://www.deviantart.com/karomataki/art/Darling-653625727 "...Commission for Eggnog from WH...."

https://www.deviantart.com/karomataki says "I'm not active here. Find me on Instagram (mataki2001)" (and "290 Deviations")

Looks like DA karomataki moved to FA mataki23, but let's get back to that LATER.

2) starting with 2nd FA upload https://www.furaffinity.net/view/36567521/
their artworks have "Mataki" on them.

I assume they went with mataki23 username because plain mataki username was already taken.
https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki/ "Registered: Nov 24, 2006".
https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki23/ "Registered: Apr 5, 2015".

( https://www.furaffinity.net/user/mataki/ says "...enjoy this fine collection of artwork by other people. I cannot draw this well....". I checked their FA uploads and none seemed to be drawn by FA/mataki. )

Updated

There's no need to make this unnecessarily complicated. Just use mataki23 for the artist, and mataki for the character (unless there are any other Matakis on here).

wat8548 said:
There's no need to make this unnecessarily complicated. Just use mataki23 for the artist, and mataki for the character (unless there are any other Matakis on here).

Amazing enough there are more matakis:

In addition to:
1) Mataki, character of FA/Mataki
2) artist Mataki23 ("Mataki" on art)
3) Mataki, character of FA/Mataki23

There are also:
1) character of FA/Cookiekaro, apparently named Mataki https://www.furaffinity.net/view/13329275/
2) Mataki, character of FA/xxoosonicxxoo, https://www.furaffinity.net/view/6715125/ (and 2 other posts in their gallery)
3) Mataki, apparently character of FA/superwolfqueen21 : https://www.furaffinity.net/view/6426992/ (some other posts in their gallery)
4) there was another one but am sleepy and forgot where it was

(possibly more, bedtime soon so rushed through FA search for "Mataki" results skipping over those that seemed to be characters I'd already found)

***

Edit: issue of artist uploading their art to e621
with e621 character tag 'mataki' (but none seem to depict their Mataki character)
Maybe alias mataki23 tag to mataki_(artist)???

(I'm assuming they indicating preference for
artist name of Mataki,
which is artist name on their art)
Hope I made sense. Sleeptime

Updated

  • 1