Topic: borders 2.0

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Watsit

Privileged

Could letterbox (and pillarbox) apply to part of an image, or something in the image? For instance a single panel in a multi-panel image, or if viewing something like a TV screen that has an image with letterboxing. I don't think meta would be appropriate for those cases (and I would support removing pillarbox from meta for that reason).

bordered should only be used for the image itself, not any picture (like a photo-frame or a TV screen) inside the image. If there is a border that goes around all the multi-panel images (in other words, if all the multiple images were changed by a single image, and the border still circles around it), bordered would apply, otherwise no. Same for letterboxed and pillarboxed.
If only portion of the image has the border I suppose the tags can't be used.

Bump. Also wouldn't an alias be better? Though I suppose letterbox might get erroneously used instead of mailbox so a mass update makes sense there. Also change category of pillarboxed to meta.

romanicyte2 said:
The bulk update request #4769 is pending approval.

mass update letterbox -> letterboxed
mass update pillarbox -> pillarboxed
mass update border -> bordered
change category letterboxed (0) -> meta
change category bordered (0) -> meta

Reason: https://e621.net/forum_topics/38412

Pillarbox already is meta.

Don't mass update border to bordered it's gonna make a mess.

The following tags are aliased to this tag: bordered_bg, bordered, borders_background, borders, border_background, border_bg, borders_bg, framed_background, bordered_background (learn more).

The following tags implicate this tag: white_border, black_border, outside_border, brown_border, red_border, pink_border, blue_border, grey_border, gradient_border, green_border, multicolored_border, orange_border, ornate_border, purple_border, striped_border, tan_border, transparent_border, yellow_border (learn more).

What's the point in doing that anyways? Border doesnt have many meanings like the 2 other tags.

Updated

  • 1