The bulk update request #5161 is active.

create implication horn_in_pussy (45) -> horn_penetration (85)
create implication horn_in_ass (17) -> horn_penetration (85)
remove implication horn_in_pussy (45) -> horn_play (466)
remove implication horn_in_ass (17) -> horn_play (466)

Reason: I'm still a little confused on horn_penetration vs horn_sex, but it matches the tentacle_penetration/tentacle_sex setup so whatever.
They can also unimply horn_play since horn_penetration implies that

EDIT: The bulk update request #5161 (forum #369867) has been approved by @slyroon.

cloudpie said:
The bulk update request #5161 is active.

create implication horn_in_pussy (45) -> horn_penetration (85)
create implication horn_in_ass (17) -> horn_penetration (85)
remove implication horn_in_pussy (45) -> horn_play (466)
remove implication horn_in_ass (17) -> horn_play (466)

Reason: I'm still a little confused on horn_penetration vs horn_sex, but it matches the tentacle_penetration/tentacle_sex setup so whatever.
They can also unimply horn_play since horn_penetration implies that

+1

Regarding tentacle_penetration/tentacle_sex, tentacle sex would refer to non-penetrative sex acts as well -- like a tentacle jerking off a dick. Tentacle penetration is just one type of tentacle sex, so tentacle_penetration should probably imply tentacle_sex. This interpretation is backed up by the wiki article for tentacle_sex where tentacle penetration is a subpoint under tentacle sex (see "Tentacle Actions" dropdown).

I suppose horn_penetration/horn_sex could be similar, if there were images of, say, a character frotting their penis against a horn. It seems less likely that this would be a common theme, but the possibility for such a distinction is there with separate tags. If we go that route, then horn_penetration should imply horn_sex.

monroethelizard said:
+1

Regarding tentacle_penetration/tentacle_sex, tentacle sex would refer to non-penetrative sex acts as well -- like a tentacle jerking off a dick. Tentacle penetration is just one type of tentacle sex, so tentacle_penetration should probably imply tentacle_sex. This interpretation is backed up by the wiki article for tentacle_sex where tentacle penetration is a subpoint under tentacle sex (see "Tentacle Actions" dropdown).

I suppose horn_penetration/horn_sex could be similar, if there were images of, say, a character frotting their penis against a horn. It seems less likely that this would be a common theme, but the possibility for such a distinction is there with separate tags. If we go that route, then horn_penetration should imply horn_sex.

Is there any type of penetration that isn't considered sex on e6? Wondering if maybe there is and that's why it's not already implicated. What about like tentacle_in_ear?

I think surely at least *_in_pussy and *_in_anus are always sex though so those should imply *_sex as well as *_penetration, even if the base penetratioj tag can't imply sex

cloudpie said:
Is there any type of penetration that isn't considered sex on e6? Wondering if maybe there is and that's why it's not already implicated. What about like tentacle_in_ear?

I think surely at least *_in_pussy and *_in_anus are always sex though so those should imply *_sex as well as *_penetration, even if the base penetratioj tag can't imply sex

Hmm. Thinking about it more, I suspect it's a matter of the participants involved. If a tentacled character is penetrating themselves, then it's not tentacle "sex", per se, but rather, masturbation. I think that'd be the best argument for why tentacle_penetration doesn't imply tentacle_sex -- kind of like how anal penetration isn't anal sex if it's anal masturbation.

Applying that to horn_penetration and horn_sex, I guess it'd be horn penetration but not horn sex if a character were flexible enough to penetrate themselves with their own horn -- or, on a potentially more macabre note, if they were to penetrate themselves with someone's removed horn.

monroethelizard said:
Hmm. Thinking about it more, I suspect it's a matter of the participants involved. If a tentacled character is penetrating themselves, then it's not tentacle "sex", per se, but rather, masturbation. I think that'd be the best argument for why tentacle_penetration doesn't imply tentacle_sex -- kind of like how anal penetration isn't anal sex if it's anal masturbation.

Applying that to horn_penetration and horn_sex, I guess it'd be horn penetration but not horn sex if a character were flexible enough to penetrate themselves with their own horn -- or, on a potentially more macabre note, if they were to penetrate themselves with someone's removed horn.

This concept exists, and it is freaky.

monroethelizard said:
Hmm. Thinking about it more, I suspect it's a matter of the participants involved. If a tentacled character is penetrating themselves, then it's not tentacle "sex", per se, but rather, masturbation. I think that'd be the best argument for why tentacle_penetration doesn't imply tentacle_sex -- kind of like how anal penetration isn't anal sex if it's anal masturbation.

Applying that to horn_penetration and horn_sex, I guess it'd be horn penetration but not horn sex if a character were flexible enough to penetrate themselves with their own horn -- or, on a potentially more macabre note, if they were to penetrate themselves with someone's removed horn.

Oh yep you're right! There are posts with both, even. I wasn't thinking lol
post #3355408 post #2584720

The bulk update request #5161 (forum #369867) has been approved by @slyroon.