Topic: taking_photo BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #6761 is pending approval.

create alias photography (167) -> taking_photo (6)
create alias taking_picture (2191) -> taking_photo (6)
create alias taking_selfie (514) -> selfie (13480)
create implication selfie (13480) -> taking_photo (6)

Reason: I feel like taking_photo is more clear than photography and just sounds better than taking_picture, but it could be flipped too ๐Ÿคท
Taking a selfie is taking a photo. That one could potentially also be flipped, idk, but selfie already has an implication.

With the selfie tag, often the taking_photo part is implied but the camera device is not shown and we only see an outstretched arm reaching into the viewer but no visual proof that a picture is being taken (e.g., camera_flash, snap or click onomatopoeia, etc). IMO taking_photo should show that visual proof or a camera with a picture-taking pose. Taking_photo could instead include the broader process of getting prepared to take a picture (posing, lighting, etc), which might be how the phrase "taking a picture" gets used IRL, but I don't think that's good for tagging.

Selfie's an odd tag because often it's only a pose + viewpoint with no camera, so a tag like selfie_pose or selfie_view would be more accurate. (selfie_pose matches naming like paw_pose, and selfie_view matches and complements camera_view in particular.) Then you have mirror_selfie that may not have a selfie pose, but we still know our viewpoint comes from the camera. Then you have selfie posts that are taking_selfie showing the pose and camera but the viewpoint is outside the camera and not the selfie itself. Unfortunately, there's no good reason to separate a tag named taking_selfie (pose + camera) from the regular selfie posts (pose + view), and for the pose + view posts taking_selfie is wholly redundant with selfie.

The selfie tag is something that I think we can organize better. Hard to say all selfie posts are a certain way, and some variations get more creative.

Examples

post #4500822 selfie pose1 + view2, no camera -- my contention is this most common selfie variant not be tagged taking_photo
post #4571179 mirror_selfie view + camera, no "selfie pose" (arguably, just a normal taking_picture pose)
post #4598725 taking_selfie pose + camera, no view
post #4551784 creative selfie with penis_shadow
1. "pose" refers to the selfie pose with an outstretched arm holding the camera away from the body
2. "view" refers to the viewpoint of the the selfie photo, the post shows the picture that the camera took

And while I'm here, a fun one: dick_pic. Arguably still a selfie with the same variations as selfies.

Examples

post #4452756 normal pose + view, no face, no camera
post #3463215 pose + view + face, no camera (but camera_view)
post #4008500 mirror_selfie view + camera + face, no "selfie pose"
post #4588349 taking_photo pose + camera + face, no view
post #2671262 classic sexting on phone_screen with view, no pose, no camera, no face -- selfie edge case --

  • 1