The tag implication #62978 football_uniform -> sportswear has been rejected.

Reason: All the other sport uniforms imply sportswear

EDIT: The tag implication football_uniform -> sportswear (forum #405070) has been rejected by @Leotheairwolf.

https://e621.net/wiki_pages/7847

kyiiel said:
https://e621.net/wiki_pages/7847

Okay, so what about disambiguating football uniform and splitting it up?
american_football_uniform, rugby_football_uniform, etc...?

leotheairwolf said:
Okay, so what about disambiguating football uniform and splitting it up?
american_football_uniform, rugby_football_uniform, etc...?

It might be worth mass updating football_uniform to american_football_uniform first (though someone needs to comb through for any soccer_uniform beforehand).
Then, directly alias football_uniform to football_(disambiguation) and give the alternatives there. Don't need multiple disambiguation pages.

In addition, there is also multiple parts of the american_football_uniform, including football_helmet, shoulder_pads, etc.
Moreover, there is also football_player that should get the same treatment.

The tag implication football_uniform -> sportswear (forum #405070) has been rejected by @Leotheairwolf.

The bulk update request #8138 is pending approval.

create alias football_uniform (136) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_gear (158) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_jersey (201) -> football_jersey_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_field (205) -> football_field_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_player (353) -> football_player_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_pants (37) -> football_legwear_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_posts (8) -> field_goal (0)
create implication american_football_uniform (89) -> sportswear (6552)
create alias football_helmet (187) -> american_football_helmet (0)
create alias football_team (2) -> sports_team (7)

Reason: I'm going through football_uniform with a TagMe Project (link for anyone who wants to contribute)
In the meantime, I figure this is a better alternative to the initial proposal

Also, using american_football_uniform instead of gridiron_uniform due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:American_football_uniforms
Though we should probably decide whether we use american_football or gridiron (akin to gridiron_ball)

EDITED: adding a few more disambiguation tags. I'm willing to go through and set up the disambiguation wikis once they're aliased.
Also, alias football_helmet -> american_football_helmet because.. afaik other forms of football don't use helmets. Rugby maybe, if you count that

dirtyderg said:
The bulk update request #8138 is pending approval.

create alias football_uniform (136) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_gear (158) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_jersey (201) -> football_jersey_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_field (205) -> football_field_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_player (353) -> football_player_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_pants (37) -> football_legwear_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_posts (8) -> field_goal (0)
create implication american_football_uniform (89) -> sportswear (6552)
create alias football_helmet (187) -> american_football_helmet (0)
create alias football_team (2) -> sports_team (7)

Reason: I'm going through football_uniform with a TagMe Project
In the meantime, I figure this is a better alternative to the initial proposal

Also, using american_football_uniform instead of gridiron_uniform due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:American_football_uniforms

EDITED: adding a few more disambiguation tags. I'm willing to go through and set up the disambiguation wikis once they're aliased.
Also, alias football_helmet -> american_football_helmet because.. afaik other forms of football don't use helmets. Rugby maybe, if you count that

Though we should probably decide whether we use american_football or gridiron (akin to gridiron_ball)

Just wanna say big thanks for putting together that list/bur! That's a really good start. As for american football vs gridiron, not sure on that.

dirtyderg said:
create alias football_uniform (182) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_gear (135) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_jersey (175) -> football_jersey_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_field (181) -> football_field_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_player (306) -> football_player_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_pants (29) -> football_legwear_(disambiguation) (0)

EDITED: adding a few more disambiguation tags. I'm willing to go through and set up the disambiguation wikis once they're aliased.

Do we really need 6 separate disambiguation pages for each article of clothing/term?

thegreatwolfgang said:
Do we really need 6 separate disambiguation pages for each article of clothing/term?

Can't wait for football_(disambiguation)_(disambiguation)

thegreatwolfgang said:
Do we really need 6 separate disambiguation pages for each article of clothing/term?

I mean, not necessarily, but it's probably better than lumping them all into football_disambiguation

We could lump all the individual articles of clothing (e.g. football_pants) into football_uniform_(disambiguation) for example.
Honestly, I don't think we need individual tags for legwear. *_uniform + legwear should be enough.
Maybe the same for jersey, though fans often wear jerseys so idk if lumping that under *_uniform is the best practice

The bulk update request #8149 is pending approval.

create alias football_uniform (136) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_gear (158) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_pants (37) -> football_uniform_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_jersey (201) -> football_jersey_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_helmet (187) -> gridiron_helmet (0)
create alias football_field (205) -> football_field_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias football_posts (8) -> field_goal (0)
create alias football_team (2) -> sports_team (7)
create alias football_player (353) -> athlete (155)
create implication american_football_uniform (89) -> sportswear (6552)

Reason:

dirtyderg said:
We could lump all the individual articles of clothing [...]

Something like this, maybe

Stop making multiple BURs of the same thing. Just edit your first BUR or stick with it.

My justification for lumping everything into football_(disambiguation) is because the sport itself and the ball has already been aliased to it.
In addition, there is no precedent to having subcategories of disambiguation tags. It's just creating a big mess that a single tag could easily fix.

thegreatwolfgang said:
Stop making multiple BURs of the same thing.

It's not the same thing. Individual disamb. vs more generic disamb.. To see what others prefer.

dirtyderg said:
It's not the same thing. Individual disamb. vs more generic disamb.. To see what others prefer.

People can remove and re-cast their votes. So you can still see what people prefer when you edit a BUR.
Also I think aliasing all of them to football_(disambiguation) is the best.